Parenting Podcast: May Their Memories Be for a Blessing

Parenting Podcast by Wendy Grinberg, RJE

When the dog died, I found myself listening to Mr. Rogers. Not because May’s death had forced me to regress to my preschool years, but because I needed advice on how to explain her death to my 2 and a half year old son. It became even more complicated when my grandmother passed away the next month. As Jewish parenting expert, clinical psychologist and author Dr. Mogel teaches us in this week’s Parenting Podcast, we need to listen carefully to what our children are asking about difficult questions, rather than project our own feelings on them. My son’s questions were: How is “dead” different than “sick” or “going bye-bye”? Will she come back? Will that happen to me when I go to the doctor? If May was old, am I old? Are Mommy and Daddy old? It was also important to me not fabricate a fantasy about where May was now that would only get more complicated as he had more questions.

When my grandmother died, part of me realized that my fears of how my son would react were really my own feelings of loss being projected my son. Mr. Rogers sings, “The very same people who are sad sometimes, are the very same people who are glad sometimes.” One of the most disconcerting aspects of the death of a loved one to a child is when the grown-ups around him or her show their sadness and loss. I’ve learned it’s important that our feelings are named and explicit, so that children can see that adults have a range of feelings as well, but those feelings are not destabilizing.

One thing that gives me great comfort is talking to him about the lives of people who have died, rather than their deaths. The other morning we went out for breakfast, and my son was enthralled with the bagel bakers and short-order cooks. I told him that his great-great grandfather was a baker, and my grandmother used to remove his shoes when he came home from work early in the morning, after baking all night. I never met my great grandfather, but this story came to me through my grandmother, and telling it to my son really pleased me. Perhaps this is the meaning of the phrase Zichronam L’vrachah, “May Their Memories Be for Blessing.”

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Download MP3

You can subscribe to the podcasts, and send us your feedback as well.

Wendy Grinberg, RJE is a URJ Parenting Specialist.

Watch Dr. Wendy Mogel’s speech at the 2011 URJ Biennial.

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Guest Blogger

About Guest Blogger accepts submissions for consideration. Send your posts to Please include biographical information, including your affiliation with any Reform congregation or institution.

One Response to “Parenting Podcast: May Their Memories Be for a Blessing”

  1. avatar

    The Rev. Dr. Fred Rogers was a genius–he REALLY knew how to explain things to children without watering down the truth too much. I’m so glad he was helpful to you in answering your son’s difficult questions. I’m probably years away from having kids of my own, and I do not look forward to having to answer those questions!
    Mr. Rogers was a profound influence on me as a young kid, and is indirectly responsible for planting within me the seeds of my two most enduring passions: music and religion. He talked about God with relative frequency on his shows, in a very generic, non-denominational sort of way, and I’ll never forget the episode in which he brought in a grand piano and a harpsichord and put them side by side for comparison. I knew from age 4 or 5 that I wanted to be a harpsichordist when I grew up. Little did I know that I’d end up considering myself more likely to be a Rabbi than a professional musician!

Leave a Reply