The Modern Day Value of Tishah B’Av

Rabbi Norman KochTemple Sholom, New Milford, CT

During the summer months the Torah’s calendar contains no holidays save the weekly blessing of Shabbat. However, post biblical historical realities bring us a most significant commemoration on Tishah B’Av, the Ninth of Av. It was on this date in the heat of summer in the year 586 B.C.E. that the Babylonians destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem. On the same date some six and a half centuries later, in the year 70 C.E., the Romans destroyed the Second Temple in Jerusalem.Twice in our long, unbroken journey through history we found our national sovereignty overthrown, the seat, symbol, and reality of our government destroyed, our country overrun by oppressive enemies, and the organizational realities of our daily lives in ruin.In the long saga of the numerous peoples and nations of the human family no group, save us, has ever outlived, overcome, and flourished beyond such overwhelming, total, and seemingly permanent national and cultural destruction.As we have lived beyond these decimations and lived beyond the many other attempts to eliminate the Jewish People from the face of the earth, Tishah B’Av has been primarily observed as a Jewish Day of Mourning. We recall the destructions and weep as we read the Book of Lamentations.In the reality of our own day, with the focus of summer being a time for vacations, relaxation, picnics, backyard barbeques, days at the beach, time on the tennis and golf courses, etc., Tishah B’Av has faded from the consciousness of most American Jews. Living as we do, we have little awareness of the “nationhood” of the Jewish People. As most moderns, we look back at ancient history as just that, ancient and history. We may study it, we may find it interesting, we may draw lessons from it, but, for the most part, it does not animate our daily living or flow through the emotional veins of our conscious daily life.Yet, even in our modern day, I believe that reclaiming and refocusing the commemoration of Tishah B’Av can offer us much of value. I see Tishah B’Av not so much as a day of mourning but as a day of morning. Yes, it does remind us of loss, of destruction, of death, of the precariousness of life; but, it also reminds us that we are still here, alive, and flourishing.I posit Tishah B’Av as morning in that after the passing of the darkest of nights we awaken to the challenge and the possibility of rebuilding, of reclaiming, of adapting to new realities, and of going forward. Hurricanes, tornadoes, tsunamis, economic upheavals, terrorist attacks, wars, and threatening enemies are still a part of life on this planet. No one of us is immune to the ravages of these things when they wash over our shores, blow through our towns, and shake the foundations of our society. Each of us must also encounter the threats and challenges to our personal lives when disease strikes, jobs are lost, loved ones die, and so many such things assail us.In pausing to commemorate on the Ninth of Av, we can remember that mourning in the face of loss need not yield to despair. The Babylonians are gone, the Romans are gone, the Inquisition is no more, and the crematoria of Hitler’s death camps no longer devour us; yet we are still here. We live, we thrive, we create, we struggle and inspire. We have adapted, we have adjusted, we have cried and used our tears to water and nourish new growth. Yes, Am Yisrael Chai, the Jewish People Lives!On Tishah B’Av, both collectively and individually, we can pause, face the reality of life’s destructive power, appropriately lament, and cry. We can also remember that, just as did our forbears, we can find strength and comfort in turning to God, we can draw on the collective, ancient, and ongoing strength and spirit of our People to maintain hope, to rebuild upon the ruins, to adjust and adapt to new realities, and to thrive. We can turn to the frame for life and tools for living to be found in our Torah and in the millennia of our encounter, interpretation, and application to life of its words and teachings.

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Guest Blogger

About Guest Blogger accepts submissions for consideration. Send your posts to Please include biographical information, including your affiliation with any Reform congregation or institution.

3 Responses to “The Modern Day Value of Tishah B’Av”

  1. Larry Kaufman

    Yasher koach! For this drash as a whole, and especially for mourning – morning.

  2. avatar

    I am a Catholic and I work for a kind Jewish gentleman. I knew it was a Jewish holiday but not one I was familiar with so I looked it up. I found your interpretation of the holiday to be uplifting at a time when there is much turmoil in our world. I will share this with him. By the way I live in New Fairfield, CT.

  3. avatar

    Those who mourn the destruction, will rejoice during our redemption…
    Thinking about what we lost(the great holy Temple in Jerusalem that connected heaven and earth, and where we really, deeply felt the presence of G-d), thinking about this helps us to yearn for the day of redemption. The time when there will finally be peace and great joy. The re-building of the great holy Temple and amazing Divine Presence felt all around.
    we can make a difference by learning about our heritage, practicing our tradition, and continuing to have faith that our joy will come.
    good info at

Leave a Reply