The Jewish State Needs to be More Jewish

Israel is a Jewish and democratic state. At times I worry whether enough is being done to maintain her democratic character, and at times I worry about whether or not we are preserving her Jewish soul. At the moment, it is the Jewish side of the equation that troubles me. This concern was brought on by two brief items in the Israeli press.

ITEM ONE: A few weeks ago, a competition was held for eighth grade students in the Israeli school system on Pirkei Avot (The Chapters of the Fathers), the ethical/legal tract from the Talmud that is studied throughout the Jewish world in the period prior to Shavuot. Students were asked questions about the text and rabbinic commentaries on the text, and the three winners – all girls – impressed those present, including Education Minister Gideon Saar, with their mastery of the material. At the end of the ceremony, Saar praised the students for “swimming in the ocean” of rabbinic wisdom, morality, and values, and expressed the view that if all Israeli children were to study Pirkei Avot, Israel would be a more enlightened country and also a less violent one. The competition came immediately after some terrible acts of violence had shaken the country, including a vicious murder by some young boys.Rabbi Eric Yoffie

As reported by Sivan Rahav-Meir, writing in the Hebrew edition of Yediot Aharonot on May 11, two Knesset members, Ilan Gilon and Dov Khenin, rushed to condemn Saar for his “unfortunate utterance,” a view seconded by others on various websites. My question: Whatever one’s level of religious observance or belief, shouldn’t it be self-evidence that serious study of Jewish texts might, just might, offer an alternative to the culture of violence to which some of Israel’s youth have been drawn? Text study is not the only answer, but surely it is part of the answer, and why in heaven’s name would such study be objectionable to members of Israel’s Parliament?

ITEM TWO:  Israel’s army has decided to recommend that a text used at Memorial Day services for fallen soldiers should say “May the nation of Israel remember” rather than “May God remember.” The decision to omit the word “God” was made by a committee appointed by the Chief of Staff and must now be approved by Defense Minister Barak.

The text, originally written by a Labor Zionist leader, was amended to include “God” after the Six-Day War, but a controversy erupted last year when a bereaved mother who is secular objected. The issue was extensively debated a year ago, but for now I will simply say that as reluctant as I am to question any bereaved parent, the fact is that the reference to God seemed not to offend anyone for over thirty years. And it is worth noting that in the United States, with its strong tradition of church-state separation, references to God in public ceremonies and documents have been judged acceptable by the courts because of their “ceremonial nature.”   Surely at a service of remembrance for fallen soldiers in the Jewish state a reference to God is not only acceptable but, indeed, appropriate and desirable.

I am committed to religious freedom in Israel and to civil and human rights for all her citizens; and I am deeply distressed by the coercive nature of Israel’s religious bureaucracy. Nonetheless, while these problems are being addressed, Israel cannot cease to be what it was created to be: a state intended to promote the religion, civilization, and culture of the Jewish people and its dominant majority. The Jewish state is to be the one place in the world where the national anthem is Jewish, where Jewish holidays provide the rhythm of the calendar, and where Jews openly apply Jewish values to every aspect of life. In such a state, it seems to me, the study of Jewish texts is encouraged and one does not hesitate to mention God on public occasions.

Originally posted on The Jerusalem Post.

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Rabbi Eric H. Yoffie

About Rabbi Eric H. Yoffie

Rabbi Eric H. Yoffie is president emeritus of the Union for Reform Judaism. He speaks and writes frequently about Israel, religious life, social justice, and other topics of interest to the Jewish community. Read his full bio and writings on the URJ website.

2 Responses to “The Jewish State Needs to be More Jewish”

  1. Larry Kaufman

    There seem to be contradictory forces at work here. Presumably the objection to girls studying Pirke Avot emanated from the religious right, and the objection to God in the memorial prayer from the ultra-secular left.

    I’m inclined to interpret the memorial prayer change as a positive move in the direction of separation of religion and state, akin to Ben Gurion’s use of Tzur Yisrael. God’s shoulders are broad enough to withstand the slight, if slight it is; girls and women in Israel have been battered enough by the forces of blackness.

  2. avatar

    Maybe I missed something here.

    Does anyone know whether the animus of the Knesset members was directed against “study of Jewish texts” (Yoffie) or “girls studying Pirke Avot” (Kaufman)?

Leave a Reply