Where Have All the Knesset Candidates Gone?

by Rabbi Meir Azari

If Moses would have had to run in a modern election – such as the one the United States just concluded and like the one we in Israel are just beginning – he likely could never have captured the hearts of the public. If King David’s scandalous court shenanigans were made public, no spin doctor would have been able to save him. And faced with today’s nonstop campaigns and coverage, it is likely that other notable Jewish leaders, including the Vilna Gaon, Ba-al Shem Tov, Rabbi Nachman from Breslau, and even David Ben-Gurion, the founding prime minister of Israel, would never have been elected to positions of influence in today’s Israel. Perhaps they would have not even sought positions of leadership at all.

The Israeli political map is being reshuffled at this very moment, with some talented and worthy people entering the political scene. But it astonishes me that, although Israeli society is so talented and creative, many exceptional Israeli minds stay clear of politics. You can count on one hand – on less than those five fingers – the creative high-tech professionals, academics, or physicians entering the political scene. Since Israel’s creation, most governments have had doctors or leading financial figures elected to the Knesset. In this coming election, there won’t be one physician candidate or a major CEO entering the ring. Here in Israel, the vibrant social protest of summer of 2011 – in which Israelis of all backgrounds protested the rising cost of living and the deterioration of public services like health and education – showed that together, we can advocate for change and make progress. But what type of leaders do we urgently need?

Jewish text can help us. In Hilochot Sanhedrin, the Jewish scholar Maimonides defines the ideal public leader as one holds seven attributes: wisdom, humility, reverence, loathing of money, love of truth, love of humanity, and a good name. I believe – as do many Israelis – that our political candidates should possess most if not all these characteristics, as you, too, expect from your candidates in North America. But today there is a feeling throughout the globe that most citizens do not have the same faith in their politicians as they did a generation ago. In Israel, this is especially dire. The existential challenges Israel faces leave no room for mistakes to be made.

It is a great challenge for a community, city, or country to find a person who will meet these high standards. But we, as Jews, are always looking for the very best. Let us hope we get close to these standards not only in January’s elections in Israel but also when we elect the leaders of our communities, synagogues, religious organizations, cities, and states.

Rabbi Meir Azari is Senior Rabbi and Executive Director of the Daniel Centers for Progressive Judaism in Tel Aviv, Israel.

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Guest Blogger

About Guest Blogger

RJ.org accepts submissions for consideration. Send your posts to rjblog@urj.org. Please include biographical information, including your affiliation with any Reform congregation or institution.

2 Responses to “Where Have All the Knesset Candidates Gone?”

  1. Larry Kaufman

    My father, a lawyer, was once offered the opportunity to become a judge, with bipartisan support. When I asked him why he had declined,, he said that he could live with the idea that people were asking “Why isn’t Louie Kaufman a judge?” but not with the idea that they might ask “By what right is Louie Kaufman a judge?”

    Even if someone meets the Rambam’s seven attributes in his own eyes, will others agree? And what about the Harry Truman standard — If you can’t stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen. Is the loss of faith in politicians that Rabbi Azari points to a cause or an effect?

    Fortunately for all of us Reform Jews and devotees of religious pluralism,, we are now grateful that Rabbi Azari’s colleague Rabbi Gilad Kariv has decided to brave the obstacles and become a candidate for a Knesset seat, so he can fight from the inside for the separation of synagogogue and state, as he has been doing so effectively until now from his position as director of the Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism. Let’s hope that Rabbi Kariv as our Nachshon inspires many more of our leaders to plunge into the deep waters and lead Israel to become the peaceful, pluralistic, Jewish, democratic society we crave.

  2. avatar

    There are few leaders with the qualities listed by Rabbi Azari who have been elected in the recent past throughout the western world. Perhaps one of the reasons is related to the expectations and demands made on those seeking public office. As Rabbi Azari correctly notes, our communities are not providing the incentives for candidates with the skills, experience and background to think about serving their communities and countries. Until and unless we adopt a more favourable attitude to public service and create the political and social environment that will attract the best and the brightest, we will continue to have a very mixed group of candidates running for political office. The CVs of many of the candidates do not qualify them for the positions they are seeking in the political arena. We need to adopt a more positive attitude to public service so that highly skilled and motivated candidates will emerge to take on the reins of leadership.
    Mark S. Anshan
    Immediate Past President, Holy Blossom Temple, Toronto
    URJ Board of Trustees

Leave a Reply