Worship Without Music?!



By Jerry Kaye

Can you imagine a worship service these days without a cantor, a song leader, or even a band? There is nowhere in the liberal Jewish community where music isn’t an integral and heartening part of worship. Today, Jewish music is readily available on CDs and MP3s, and even on YouTube, which hosts thousands of new Jewish music recordings as well as the classics.

Were worship and music always intertwined? Is music as important in the traditional community? Can you pray without a guitar or keyboard? As far back as biblical times, Psalms describes praising God with the harp, lute and timbrel, thus giving us a great musical inheritance. However, we don’t know the melodies that David sang or the songs that surrounded Solomon.

Debbie Friedman, of blessed memory, transformed the music of the bimah and Jewish camps. There were many before her – including Rabbi Shlomo Carlebach and a group of United Synagogue Youth grads called Arba Kolot (Four Voices)-who took language from the prayer book and generated it into music. Theo Bikel, Geula Gil, and Chava Alberstam made “Israeli music” feel like the ‘new’ Jewish music. But Israeli music, engaging as it is, really never took the bimah like Debbie Friedman.

Musical change was in the air when Debbie Friedman, Jeff Klepper, and Rabbi Dan Freelander joined liturgy with melody. Debbie may have been the first to bring Hebrew and English together in her songs, which made her music accessible whether you spoke Hebrew or not. Danny, Jeff and the entire NFTY community imprinted the new music first on records, then on cassettes, and ultimately as downloads.

Today, the list of Jewish composers, performers, and service leaders has grown long, and includes notables like Josh Nelson, Rabbi Ken Chasen, Cantors Rosalie Boxt, Arik Luck, Ellen Dreskin, and Shira Klein.

The bedrock of Jewish music can be found in the musical history of our URJ camps. Since our camps don’t have pipe organs, the front lines of Jewish folk music were acoustic guitar. Campers – teens and tweens – could pick up guitars and learn the minor chords of Jewish melodies. Even those who weren’t good pickers found that it sure was fun to sing along. Scores of kids who resisted piano lessons at home were excited to enthusiastically sing after camp lunch, and many signed up for guitar chug (club) before they even got off the camp bus.

As a result, Hebrew music and Jewish themes became embedded in the culture of Jewish camp. Camp services evolved from being peppered with Hebrew words here and there, to being imbued with Hebrew. This musical sea change at camps led to the cantorial resistance of the 60s and early 70s, when campers returned home and wondered why temple services weren’t as friendly as their camp services had been.

Although that generation of chazanim can’t be held responsible for what they were taught and what their congregations accepted as familiar, those young camp song leaders redirected their focus to become cantors and music directors themselves, and the change transformed Reform congregations everywhere. So it is that the music of Jeff and Danny and Debbie and so many more have made camp come alive with the strings, the flute and the timbrel.

Jerry Kaye is the Director of the URJ Olin-Sang-Ruby Union Institute in Oconomowoc, Wisconsin and was one of just 30 people from around the world invited to join the International Task Force on Jewish Peoplehood, under the auspices of the Jewish Agency. This past year he was appointed to a prestigious national panel on Jewish Educational Leadership as the only camp director among university professors and other practitioners of work in Jewish life.

Print Friendly
Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email
Guest Blogger

About Guest Blogger

RJ.org accepts submissions for consideration. Send your posts to rjblog@urj.org. Please include biographical information, including your affiliation with any Reform congregation or institution.

One Response to “Worship Without Music?!”

  1. avatar

    To everything there is a season….

    It took the revolution of the 1960′s to make it possible for all of this change within music for worship, and it took the freedom and magic of summer camp to make exploration and growth happen at a fast rate.

    When these pioneers returned from summer camp, they were at first told that it would be difficult to change the music of the services- which at the time were also in various stages of change from ‘music director and choir led’ to being led by cantors graduating from HUC and the School of Sacred Music (which only now bears Debbie’s name).

    Even Debbie herself has been known to say, “I like ice cream, but even I can’t survive on ice cream alone,” which is an acknowledgement of the reality that although contemporary Jewish music is currently the accepted style, there are many congregations that make great efforts to retain their own unique histories. Many places do not want to rush quickly into giving up their more ‘classical’ Reform roots or repertoires, nor should they have to.

    I think that cantors today owe a great deal to Debbie, Jeff, Danny, Loui and so many others who took a chance and kept singing the music that moved them in their youth groups. Eventually, as Jerry pointed out, they grew up to become leaders where they could insist on making the soundtrack of their collective souls into the music we can all pray together with. Or at the very least, we have many more options and the freedom to choose from.

    Many blessings,
    Cantor Brad Hyman

Leave a Reply

*