Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism
XML Google Reader or Homepage Add to My Yahoo!

Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL

Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Rss fwd

Add to Technorati Favorites! Add to your phone

Subscribe to this blog's feed
[What is this?]

Powered by
Movable Type 4.1

« November 2008 | Main | January 2009 »

December 31, 2008

The Jewish Ritual of Gift-Giving

Daphne Price is Rabbi David Saperstein's Executive Assistant.

Ours is a family of many rituals and customs. My husband and I keep a kosher home. We observe Shabbat. My husband prays 3 times a day. I study. When we celebrate the Jewish holidays, we infuse into our observance various practices from each of our own childhood homes. We provide our children a Jewish education. With traditions abound, Judaism permeates our home.

About 2 years ago, my then-2-and-a-half year old started her own tradition. My husband took her to one of those pottery painting places and she decided to paint a Tzedaka Duck." Since then, she's added to her collection a Tzedaka dalmation, a Tzedaka Nemo, a Tzedaka flower, a Tzedaka elephant, and of course, my favorite, her Tzedaka pig. To most children, these are all just piggy banks, but for my daughter, they are places where she collects and stores Tzedaka - charity for the poor. Every time she finds some coins lying around, she asks if she can put them into one of her Tzedakas. Over time, her crew of hand-painted Tzedaka banks has accumulated (literally!) a nice chunk of change.

Last evening, my now 4-and-a-half year old asked me when we were going to give her Tzedaka coins to poor people. And she got me thinking.

Today, we're starting a new tradition. Today, I am taking my daughter, along with her collection of Tzedaka banks to the bank. Together, we'll empty their contents into one of those coin counting machines to convert the coins into bills. And with the understanding that her grown-up looking money will go to someone in need, we'll give it to a worthy charity. And then we'll do the same thing next year. And the year after that. And as my kids grow older (in a couple of years, my other daughter will be old enough to participate and understand), we'll discuss various worthy charities and eventually, they'll be able to choose on their own where their money should go.

We all know that it is important to help those in need. I think it's even more important to teach our little ones the importance of giving, especially during these challenging times. We can do this both by teaching them how to give of their own money and by modeling giving ourselves. There is no shortage of worthy causes. And if you want to think about making a gift through one of the URJ causes, there are several to choose from, including Nothing But Nets, Keren B'Kavod, and, of course, the RAC. And whether we give out of our wallets or volunteer our time, we should all strive to make the act of giving a little Tzedaka a part of our own family Jewish traditions.

A New Approach in Washington

First posted at RJ.org by Gardening Grandma.

This week's US News and World Report takes a look about how President-Elect Obama is consulting with religious groups across the spectrum on issues ranging from domestic poverty to bringing peace to the Middle East.

This is the most extensive outreach and listening tour that I've ever seen a new administration take, and that is certainly true of their outreach to the faith community," said Rabbi David Saperstein, director of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, who has worked with presidential transition teams going back to Jimmy Carter's.

It's a remarkable departure from the Bush administration's approach. . As Tanya Clay House, director of public policy for People of the American Way said, "The old administration listened to just one side of the argument."

December 30, 2008

8 Reasons to be a Feminist

The Tygrrrr Express, a conservative blog recently added to The Jewish Journal of Los Angeles website, posted a blog on December 24th titled "Lighting Candles and Smacking Women: 2008 Hanukkah Style." (This particular post has been removed from The Jewish Journal's website.) Apparently intended to be comedic, this blog post is every bit as appallingly offensive as it sounds. 

According to The Tygrrrr Express, "women have been up in arms looking for ways to exact vengeance on the male gender." Feminism--the belief in the right of women to have political, social, and economic equality with men--the blog writes, "is about attempting to destroy men."

Am I missing the punch line? 

By some twisted logic of inappropriate humor, the author was compelled to make a list of "8 situations where it is perfectly acceptable to abuse women physically, sexually, or psychologically." Feel free to read the blog - I am simply too disgusted to recap the list here.

Instead, I've decided to respond with my own (admittedly belated) Hanukkah list of 2008: 

8 Reasons to be a Feminist

8) Sarah, Rebecca, Leah and Rachel. From the matriarchs of the Torah we learn that Jewish women are brave, strong, independent and determined. Indeed, it has been said that the matriarchs had a greater degree of binah--intuition, understanding, intelligence--than the patriarchs.

7) Susan, Margaret, Betty and Hillary. That's Susan B. Anthony, Margaret Sanger, Betty Friedan, and Hillary Clinton - four fabulous feminists. Thanks to these women and others like them, American women today have the right to vote, to go to college, to apply for any job, to get paid as much as men doing the same job, to take birth control, to have a fair trial as a rape victim, to have an abortion, and to expect to be treated as equals.

6) Men Still Rule the World. Well, at least the United States. The U.S. ranks 82nd worldwide in the percentage of women in our national legislature. Even after the gains women made this election cycle, 84 percent of the members of the House and Senate are male. 82 percent of state governors are male. 78 percent of state legislators throughout the country are male. 80 percent of big city mayors are male. Last I checked, half (at least) of the world was female - we need some representation!

5) Women on Welfare. Since the passage of the 1996 federal welfare law, growing numbers of welfare clients, who are disproportionately women and children, face tougher rules to receive benefits. While some women on welfare find jobs, many remain stuck in poverty because minimum wage is insufficient. Still others are unable to find stable jobs in an uneven and unpredictable economy. And for all women on welfare, the struggle to find quality, affordable child care, particularly for those working night shifts or irregular hours, is often hard to overcome.

4) Women around the World. In many countries around the world, women are raped, abused and generally treated as second-class citizens. Some horrifying facts about the status of women around the world:
  • Gender-based violence against women - female infanticide, sexual trafficking and exploitation, dowry killings and domestic violence - causes more death and disability among women in the 15 to 44 age group than cancer, malaria, traffic accidents and war combined.
  • Of the estimated 40 million people worldwide living with HIV, about 2/3 are in sub-Saharan Africa, and young women are 2.5 times more likely to be infected as their male counterparts.
  • Some countries still do not have universal suffrage. Among them are Brunei, Kuwait, Oman, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates.
  • Of the world's 979 million illiterate adults, two-thirds are women.

3) The Rollback of Reproductive Rights. States have become the testing grounds for anti-choice legislation, and the past 30 years have seen an incremental stripping away of reproductive rights at the state level. Such laws include mandatory delays and biased counseling requirements, "partial birth" abortion bans, parental consent for abortion, restrictions on low-income women's access to family planning, and even near-total abortion bans.

2) Equal Pay for Equal Work? Not Yet. Though the number has narrowed slightly in recent years, women continue to earn significantly less than their male coworkers doing the same job. Women who work full time made about 79% as much as full-time male workers in 2007. According to the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, women earned 80.4 percent as much as men in 2004. This gender pay gap exists even at the very top of the corporate chain: female CEO pay packages are only about 85% of male total actual pay. 

1) "A feminist is anyone who recognizes the equality and full humanity of women and men." -Gloria Steinem

Top 10 Religion Stories of 2008

As 2008 draws to a close, Top 10 lists abound.  This week, ReligionClause, one of the preeminent blogs on separation of church and state, posted a list of the Top Ten Developments in Church-State Separation/ Free-Exercise of Religion in 2008.  Also weighing in with Top 10 lists of their own: The Religious Newswriters Association, Time Magazine, and Rev. Paul Raushenbush via The Huffington Post.  The lists of notable stories range far and wide from controversial pastors to presidential faith outreach, from un-kosher kosher meat to a Jewish financier swindling philanthropies, so check out these lists, see which stories made it to the top, and leave us a comment here on the RACBlog and let us know what you think: What story would you have put at number one?  Were there any stories you would have added to the list?


December 29, 2008

Experiencing Chanukah through Rebuilding

Jacob Pactor lives in Indianapolis, Indiana, where he teaches high school English.

I could neither have asked for a more appropriate Chanukah gift nor found a better way to connect with its story of destruction, belief and rebuilding then my week-long trip to New Orleans with the Reform Movement's Tzevet Mitzvot: Adult Mitzvah Corps.

I arrived in the broken city of New Orleans a bit broken and disillusioned myself. I felt incomplete - many of us felt a similar absence - and a bit drawn to being in a city that seemed so far removed from my daily toils. Within hours of meeting everyone, touring the city and meeting volunteers, we just wanted to get to work.

And work we did. Working with Rebuilding Together, seven of us built a fence around a house in the Broadmoor neighborhood of New Orleans (The other 29 participants painted a nearby house). None in our group had built a fence, but we poured and mixed cement, situated and leveled support posts and aligned and screw 175-plus fence posts. Three days later, we finished our task.

However, three years after Hurricane Katrina and the broken levees, there still is no grocery or convenience store within 15 minutes of our fence. Rooted two feet deep into the earth, though, the fence reaffirms these neighbors' commitment to rebuilding their homes and lives. While the fence does separate their houses, it returns them to a pre-flood normalcy. In that way, the fence reestablishes the delicate balance between these two families as they deal with the cracked foundations in their lives and communities.

Likewise, erecting a fence and painting a house reestablished for me - for all of us - a commitment to rebuild New Orleans, our own neighborhoods and our lives. In New Orleans, so many people said "Thank you," but it is all of us who thank them when we volunteer.

122908JacobPactor
Pictured in blue shirts, clockwise from back left corner, are Adult Mitzvah Corps participants Steven Morris, Jeff Ewan, Seth Shapiro, Dan Utley, Jacob, Pactor, Judith Forman and Alison Lobron, with Adam Weingarten of Rebuilding Together New Orleans (red shirt). The group poses in front of the fence they constructed around a New Orleans home damaged by Hurricane Katrina.

Praying with their Hands: Reflecting on New Orleans

While Jews across the country spent the Christmas holiday gorging on Chinese food and taking in a good movie (or two... or three), a group of young Jewish adults spent last week repairing the world - or, more specifically, repairing New Orleans.

Twenty-nine volunteers aged 25-35 participated in the Reform Movement's Young Adult Mitzvah Corps, spending five days doing hard work in the Big Easy by repairing some of the extensive damage Hurricane Katrina did to a residential home in the Lower 9th Ward. Group co-leaders Barb Weinstein (Legislative Director of the RAC) and Naomi Abelson (Manager of Congregational Relations for the Commission on Social Action) wrote a blog post every day of the trip and microblogged on Twitter, chronicling their experiences volunteering, worshipping and socializing in New Orleans. The local news station even took notice, covering the URJ volunteers' work in a Christmas Eve news package that interviews Naomi.

Abraham Joshua Heschel once said that when he marched for civil rights in Selma, Alabama, he felt as though his feet were praying. Last week's volunteers displayed a similar philosophy, getting down to the dirty, physical aspect of volunteer work by painting, hammering, nailing and creating; in every sense of the words, they were certainly praying with their hands. And though their trip is over, the impact is lasting - the house the Young Adult Mitzvah Corps participants helped rebuild will be worked on by volunteers from other organizations until its completion - and the same can be said, we hope, about the entire city of New Orleans.

Remembering a Giant: Arnold Jacob Wolf

ElliottKleinman.jpg

Rabbi Elliott A. Kleinman is the Union for Reform Judaism's Chief Program Officer.

When I learned of Rabbi Arnold Wolf's death on Wednesday evening, I was overwhelmed by the loss. Arnold was my rabbi. My parents were founders of Congregation Solel in Highland Park, IL, and Arnold has been a part of every moment of my life. It was Arnold who inspired me to be a rabbi and challenged me to be a Jew, and it was Arnold who taught me how to do both.

Some of my earliest memories are of Arnold berating our congregation or our religious school class or the board of the congregation for not doing enough in the pursuit of justice. What I remember most is that we loved every moment of it. God was real and I "had better pay attention" he would remind us. "I am Adonai your God" was not a promise but a challenged to be lived up to every moment in every action.
I remember one such moment in religious school. Our class of fourth or fifth graders was creating our own midrashim for stories about Abraham and Rabbi Wolf walked in. He asked about a couple of the midrashim and then, in response to one, startled us all saying, "Nope, that's not what God was saying." We were crushed. But just as quickly he reminded us that the Torah was ours to own and understand, saying, "You're not listening hard enough. If you listen very carefully, you'll hear what God was saying." Wow - even I, a kid, could hear what God was saying to us. The world was never the same.

In the end though, it was Arnold's smile that gave it all away. The twinkle in his eye that reminded us that he believed in us, hoped for us and was always there to be supportive is us as we journeyed through life.

A review of the daily report from the Union's Development Department on the day of Arnold's death reminded me again of what kind of rabbi Arnold was. The second to last name on the report was Arnold's for having made a donation to the Union's Nothing But Nets campaign. It is only fitting that we were reminded of his many acts of tzedakah on that day.

Arnold and I spoke periodically. We would talk about issues of the day, my work at the Union and our families. Whenever we spoke he asked the same question, "Kleinman, you still Jewish?" If I answered yes he would ask if I could prove it. Over time I learned that, for Arnold, the right response was, "I'm still trying." That answer would appease him and continue to challenge me. Just what he wanted.

Even at this season of light, the world is a bit darker now. I'm still trying, but it is harder now without Arnold's wisdom, advice, humor and vision. The world will never be the same but always be better because of Arnold Jacob Wolf.

(A note: President-elect Barack Obama sent a powerful letter about Arnold that was read at the funeral. You can find it here.)

December 23, 2008

Live from New Orleans: Eves on the Eve of the Eve

Naomi Abelson is blogging from New Orleans, Louisiana, where she is leading the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Adult Mitzvah Corps program this week.

Work day 2? Check! With the warmer weather lifting our spirits, our crew climbed higher ladders to perfect our paint job from the eves to the ground. Yesterday we arrived to our worksite to a house partially primed and yet to be painted. As amateur painters, we were slow to develop techniques for building scaffolding, adjusting ladders and brushstroke techniques... but today our crew was up in the rafters in no time! Singing along to the radio (and oftentimes to our own little tunes) made our work day go by quickly and enjoyably.
On our second worksite, the crew of seven spent the day building a fence. In two short days, they dug holes, mixed cement, played with power tools, placed posts, and have turned a pile of two-by-fours into a fence!

It's quite rewarding to see our progress throughout the day and similarly gratifying to visit with the homeowners and neighbors - hearing their stories and learning about the local community. Walking away from the work site today, we were sore, tired and covered in paint... not that anyone on Bourbon St. will notice!

Pouring white paint for the window frames
YAMC154

Jews with power tools!
YAMC166

Building a fence
YAMC176.jpg

Relaxing during a much-needed lunch break.
YAMC196.jpg

Visiting with the homeowner, Willie, at the end of Work Day 2
YAMC206.jpg

Paint, paint everywhere!
YAMC222.jpg

Our Katrina - A Message from Detroit

RabbiRomanRabbi Norman Roman is the rabbi at Temple Kol Ami in West Bloomfield, MI. This post is adapted from Rabbi Roman's message in the January 2009 Kol Ami bulletin.

Early in December, I was invited by Cardinal Adam Maida to attend a small gathering of Detroit area religious leaders, an urgent interfaith response to the economic crisis and the auto industry's needs. It was good for the 14 of us to be together (14 is, of course, a 'yad' - a helping hand, in Hebrew!), the news media reported on our meeting, some ideas were shared of what our various communities were doing in Churches, Mosques, and Synagogues to assist our members, and personal connections were made for future participation in "prayer, political action, and programming."
Several insights from this crisis are very clear to me, and others have been suggested for me (and you) to consider:

First, what is happening in Southeast Michigan especially, is what I am calling "our area's Katrina". It is a monster storm that in some ways was expected, but its catastrophic consequences are yet to be fully grasped. On the horizon are winds of change: total disruption of home, professional and family life for many. Countless numbers of our friends and neighbors will need (or already are in need of) new jobs, new residences, and most importantly, hope. Other areas of the country received 'help' very quickly, some without too many conditions attached. But in our area's situation, there have been repercussions and threats, Congressional hearings, and scapegoating. Washington, and much of the U.S. do not seem to comprehend the extent of this crisis (the size of the hurricane), how many people outside the immediate area will be affected (the levies will break), nor has anyone prepared adequately for the rescue and clean-up operations that will be necessary (FEMA's failure). Is this possibly because many see this crisis as an opportunity to 'break' the labor unions? Or, as we heard in the accusations of racism towards New Orleans, is Detroit also being 'sacrificed' because the population is predominantly black?

Secondly, even though a loan package or other assistance may have been legislated by the time 2009 begins, a new government, with a new President and a new Congressional Majority, will take office in January. We must communicate with Washington about support for our area, our manufacturing industries, and the Main Street versus Wall Street divide that has become so real during this Recession. And more, we must share our pain and our stories with our relatives and friends who live in other parts of the country. For apparently, they and their representatives in the House and Senate refuse to see the human effect that this crisis has brought. They do not accept that failures and foreclosures and plant closings in Michigan will inevitably also mean failures and foreclosures and closings in the South, as well. They refuse to acknowledge the major advances that the American automotive companies have achieved in the last few years. We need their voices to be heard on our behalf, and we need their prayers, as well.

This is a very difficult time - for all of us. Again, please know that the Temple is here for you: we pledge to listen, to advocate on your behalf, to try and make connections for job placement or other types of assistance. The key phrase for our Jewish community and for our congregation recently has been, "No One is Alone." Our tradition teaches both that we should not despair and that we should always stand ready to help.

As Jews and as Americans, let us proudly welcome the New Year and the New Administration, and let us work and pray for a better tomorrow!

December 22, 2008

Live from New Orleans: Lips Blue, Energy High

Barb Weinstein is blogging from New Orleans, Louisiana, where she is co-leading the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Young Adult Mitzvah Corps program this week.

Today was our first (and hopefully coldest) day volunteering with Rebuilding Together New Orleans (RTNO). We are working on a house in the Broadmoor neighborhood, which was badly damaged by the Katrina floods. The owner of "our" house has lived in it for more than 20 years and raised his three sons there.

Our group arrived at the house this morning around 8:30, each of us dressed in multiple layers to fight off the 35 degree weather. Our job for the week involves scraping and painting the exterior of the two-story home. Of course, reaching the top of the house means first constructing three levels of scaffolding. It was an excellent metaphor for the way the city as a whole seems to be reviving: well-intentioned volunteers with little or no expertise in the field they are thrown into are determined to overcome the obstacles and succeed. And so, about an hour later, the scaffolding was up and the work began on a long day of physical labor. Over the hours, the house exterior became a cheerful shade of blue, almost matching the blue many of our lips were turning in the near-freezing temperatures.

Our evening program was a pizza dinner at Moishe House, meeting with four 20-something young adults who came to NOLA post-Katrina to help create a new and vibrant community. Our speakers, along with the two young AmeriCorps volunteers who are managing our work site, are indicative of what a draw this city is for people who are energetic and want to be a part of a grand revitalization effort.

**********


And now: Photos from our experiences thus far!

Participants Judith Forman and Ronnie Conn get pumped up during icebreakers at the start of our trip.
YAMC011

Breakfasting at the famous (and recently kosherized!) Café du Monde
YAMC013

Young Adult Mitzvah Corps participants pose outside Café du Monde during a little bit of bonding time
YAMC024

Morning services on the Mississippi River
YAMC026

The group visits flooded Congregation Beth Israel during a New Orleans area tour
YAMC051

Bailey London leads YAMC participants in celebrating the first night of Chanukah.
YAMC072

YAMC participants brave the cold to paint a home with Rebuilding Together New Orleans. YAMC081

December 21, 2008

Live from New Orleans: Lowers & Uppers

Barb Weinstein is blogging from New Orleans, Louisiana, where she is leading the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Adult Mitzvah Corps program this week.

This morning, despite weather delays from coast to coast, our Mitzvah Corps group was finally complete. We started the day together with breakfast at Café du Monde. As we prepare to celebrate the 1st night of Hanukkah, the beignets, which I believe are 1% flour and 99% oil, seemed particularly appropriate. After we each shook the powered sugar off our clothes, we strolled along the picturesque Riverwalk and chose a spot for our shacharit service. New Orleans is a city of great music, and while I can't honestly say we were the best ensemble in town today, we were enthusiastic in our prayers and songs.

We spent this afternoon touring the city with Rabbi Bob Loewy of Congregation Gates of Prayer in Metairie, a NOLA suburb. As I mentioned in my blog post of a couple of days ago, our hotel is in the relatively unscathed French Quarter and there are few signs of the devastation that hit the rest of the city. Today, we saw those signs everywhere.

In each neighborhood there are 3 types of homes: 1) Those that have been completely rebuilt from the foundation up and show no signs of hurricane damage, but that by virtue of their very newness are evidence of the extent of the damage that once was. 2) Those that are refurbished, often with faded (or fully visible) spray paint markings on the outside indicating an inspection by a search and rescue team in the days after the storm (including a number noting the number of bodies found) and 3) Those that remain abandoned, their owners unwilling or unable to return. There is also a 4th kind of "home," though that is really a misnomer: the empty lots. These are spaces, most clearly seen in the lower 9th ward, where there is only a foundational slab of concrete indicating where a house once was. Now, there is nothing there but weeds.

Much of the lower 9th ward was washed away when the levee, in whose shadow it existed, broke in the middle of the night. People were washed away in their sleep, lives ended and upended in an instant. The neighborhood was originally laid out in a neat grid. Now maybe one or two remnants of houses remain on each block. A handful has been rebuilt. But the area is for all intents and purposes a ghost town. Driving down the streets in a bus, there is a sense of the absurd as we come to the stop signs at each corner. Who are we stopping for? There is no one here.

We later visited Beth Israel Congregation, in the Lake Vista neighborhood, which was at one point under 15 feet of water. Jackie Gothard, who was the congregation's president in 2005, walked us through the ground floor. There is still shattered glass, upended furniture, boarded up walls and the pervasive smell of mold and dust. The congregation is not planning to reopen the facility; the devastation was too complete.

Those are a just a few of the difficult sites and stories we saw heard today. But we also saw the work of "Common Ground," a volunteer-based organization in the lower 9th that is building homes and bringing families back one at a time. We heard about ways in which the community, Jewish and otherwise, has become closer and more cooperative than it was before the storm. And we also heard over and over again, "thank you for coming here to help."

December 20, 2008

Live from New Orleans: Southern Hospitality

Naomi Abelson is blogging from New Orleans, Louisiana, where she is leading the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Adult Mitzvah Corps program this week.

Day 2: Shabbat Shalom, y'all! The sun is bright and the weather's warm here in New Orleans... but unfortunately I can't say the same for the rest of the country. More than half our group is experiencing flight delays due to snow, ice and (apparently) required "R&R ground time" for pilots & flight attendants who were working late last night/early this morning). Here's hoping everyone makes it to New Orleans safe, sound and soon!

Yesterday was spent prepping for the trip - getting supplies, reviewing schedules, organizing materials - but we did take a break for a little 'Nawlins-style dinner. As we gorged ourselves on redfish, cornbread and bananas foster bread pudding (yes, it was as delicious as it sounds!), we talked about how pleasantly surprised we've been with New Orleansians' friendly, polite and courteous demeanor. From the bellmen to the customers in line at grocery store, "southern hospitality" is true to form.

This pleasantry goes beyond a simple smile; it is a genuine interest in where we are from and why we are here. And when told we're a volunteer group, the response has always been a giant "Thank you! It really means a lot for you to continue this much-needed rebuilding work."

And once all of the delayed flights have finally landed in New Orleans, we're looking forward to the 27 Mitzvah Corps participants feeling this same warmth and gratitude. Here's looking forward to a "shavuah tov!"

Live from New Orleans: A Winn-Dixie Shabbat

Barb Weinstein is blogging from New Orleans, Louisiana, where she is leading the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Adult Mitzvah Corps program this week.

Day 1 in New Orleans is drawing to a close and the highlight thus far has been....a trip to Winn Dixie. One hundred granola bars an 80 apples later (plus a couple of hundred dollars more in sundries for our group for the week) and we are ready to go.

In just the short 12 hours since I landed in town, I am already reminded of the dichotomy that is New Orleans. Walking through the French Quarter, the party is as lively as ever. Revelers are soaking up the warm air, good food, and abundant (and creative) drinks. And yet, drive a few blocks and the boarded up buildings, empty store fronts, and obvious poverty are as present as ever.

Tomorrow we will welcome our 27 Mitzvah Corps participants and begin our week together with a dinner and Havdalah service. The theme for the night's program is "Separation," riffing on the divide between Shabbat and the work week. This for me, as I am sure for many on our trip, will be a week of work unlike most. I'm looking forward to trading my pen and computer for a hammer and paint brush.

December 19, 2008

The RAC is blogging from New Orleans!

Thirty young Jewish adults took off for New Orleans, Louisiana this morning to help rebuild the city's 9th Ward, still damaged from 2005's Hurricane Katrina. These volunteers are participating in the Union for Reform Judaism's Tzevet Mitzvot: Young Adult Mitzvah Corps program, which combines five days of social action, worship and fun in the Big Easy.

Want to follow along with their NOLA adventure? Good news - they'll be blogging about it like crazy! The trip is being led by Barb Weinstein, legislative director of the Religious Action Center, and Naomi Abelson, manager of congregational relations of the Commission on Social Action - both will be live-blogging about the group's experiences in New Orleans. You can check them out here at the RACblog, where we'll post daily updates until their trip ends on Christmas Day.

One more thing: If you want to be even more Web-savvy than standard blogging, check out the RAC on social networking Web site Twitter, where Barb will be "microblogging" more than daily with updates both large and small about what the group is up to.

And don't forget: You can let Barb, Naomi, and the rest of the group know that you're following along with their trip by commenting on their posts!

Why We Do the Work We Do

Six times a year, the RAC staff has the opportunity to work with incredible groups of high school students from across the country at our Bernard and Audre Rapoport L'Taken Social Justice Seminars.  A few weeks ago, at our first L'Taken of the year, one of our participants, Andrew Turell from Woodlands Community Temple in White Plains, NY, delivered a remarkable speech concluding his group's visit to Representative Nita Lowey's office.  Andrew's speech did not merely tie together the five separate issues on which his peers spoke.  Andrew's speech eloquently reminded us all how important his voice and the voices of his peers are.  It reminded us all why we must engage in social justice and constantly fight to make the world better.  It reminded me why it is that I love the work that we do--

"I would like to end with a quotation made famous by Robert Kennedy.  He said: 'Some men see things as they are and say why.  I dream things that never were and say why not.'  We are the future of this country--the future doctors, the future businesswomen, the future parents, the future artists, and the future statesmen.  We all have dreams about how our country can become even greater, and our work towards those dreams begins today.  Like Robert Kennedy, we will not accept the present when there is the potential for better.  We will not accept precedent when the logic is flawed.  We will not accept mediocrity when Americans deserve excellence.  Our work begins today, and we appreciate Congresswoman Lowey's support."

A New Chapter

courtdaylogo.pngThis week, the URJ began an exciting new chapter in its work on the Federal Courts. As we have documented and repeated in various "Focus on the Court" postings, recent court decisions and trends, largely a consequence of the changing makeup of the judiciary during George W. Bush's presidency, present serious threats to the fundamental rights that the Union for Reform Judaism (URJ) has long supported, among them religious liberty, free speech, privacy, civil rights, and employment non-discrimination.

In 2002, the URJ adopted policy that allows us to oppose nominees to the federal bench whose appointments would threaten fundamental rights.  This policy has allowed us to speak out against nominees like Samuel Alito, Richard Honaker, and William Pryor, whose records and statements led us to believe that their ascensions to the bench would have serious, negative consequences.
 
This past weekend, at a meeting in Tampa, Florida, the URJ Board of Trustees passed a resolution that will allow the URJ, in a highly selective manner, to support qualified nominees who are being attacked or criticized based on "their records or stated views related to the protection of the fundamental rights that our Movement supports" and/or "based on aspects of their personal identities that are irrelevant to their ability to fulfill the responsibilities of the positions to which they are nominated (including but not limited to sexual orientation, gender, race, disability, ethnicity, or religion)."

The passage of this policy is one piece of the Union for Reform Judaism's ongoing effort to amplify the progressive religious voice on judicial nominations.  Therefore, in conjunction with the passage of this policy, the RAC also resumed distribution of Rights in Peril: Why the American Jewish Community and Other Cannot Afford to Sit Out the Debate Over Judicial Nominations.

This report is a call to action to the Jewish and broader religious communities to protect fundamental rights by expanding their engagement with Judicial Branch nominations.  These groups have long been at the forefront of legislative efforts to protect fundamental rights and liberties. But too many religious organizations choose not to participate in debates over judicial appointees.  In the words of the report, "sitting out these vital debates jeopardizes crucial gains we have made and will make in the legislative arena."

We hope this report will be well-received and that the URJ's policies will serve as a model for all Jewish and national religious organizations beginning or continuing engagement in the federal judicial nominations process. 

 

December 18, 2008

A Happy Anniversary

Yesterday marked the one-year anniversary of New Jersey's abolition of the death penalty, a move that made it the one and only state that has "repealed the death penalty by legislative means" instead of as the result of a court order.  Earlier this week, the New Jersey Star Ledger published a comprehensive assessment of "justice without [the] death penalty."  In a statement yesterday, New Jersey State Senator Raymond Lesniak (who introduced the bill a year ago) reminded us all that "New Jersey's efforts now serve as a guiding light for other states" as "measures to repeal the death penalty are gaining traction all across the nation" in Maryland, New Mexico.  Though our work is far from done, we can take encouragement from victories such as this as we continue to fight for an end to capital punishment nationwide.

Hitting the Hill (During the Holidays!)

Over the past few weeks, I have had the pleasure of meeting over 500 high school students from across the country at the Religious Action Center's Bernard and Audre Rapoport L'Taken social justice seminars. Each four-day intensive learning program brings students from across the country to D.C. to learn about social justice and Jewish values (read what some of the participants had to say about their experience). The program culminates with a visit to Capitol Hill, where students meet with their Senators, Representatives and their staff to discuss the issues that matter most to them. As my fellow RAC staff and I led the participants past the Capitol and Supreme Court to their meetings, I got several interesting questions about my experiences on the Hill: "Oh, you must be here all the time, what's your favorite place to go eat?; Who is the most famous Senator/Member of Congress you have ever met?; Do you ever see the President??"
I answer honestly that visiting the Hill is only one of the many activities included in my job description. Even as full-time advocates, walking the halls of Congress and hobnobbing with the Hill crowd is not something I do on a daily basis. However, lately I've gotten to travel to the House and Senate more often, meeting with Hill staffers and members of the Obama transition team along with our partners at other faith groups. While these meetings are interesting and informative, it is often a challenge to translate our visits into the change we want (and need) to see on the issues that matter most to us.

During the holiday season we are often focused on spending time with friends and family, and intentionally disconnect from our 'everyday' lives. While this break is important and often necessary, we cannot forget our long-term goals and the steps we must take to achieve them. As the new administration and Congress prepare to take office in January, we have a unique opportunity to shape the agenda by making our voices heard on the climate and energy issues that matter so much to our community. We have an opportunity to act now, and must continue to raise our voices to keep the environment on the agenda, especially during these hard economic times. I encourage you to take break from your break this Chanukah and take action by urging the President-elect to make climate change a priority in the first 100 days of his administration, calling on Congress to pass a real, green stimulus, advocating for clean water, and more. It may be the best gift you can give to your loved ones this holiday season, and you don't even have to travel to the Hill to do it.

December 17, 2008

Good Things Come in Threes

Three developments this past week have provided good news for the anti-torture movement: the U.S. Supreme Court ordered the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals to retry a case which could result in detainees gaining "some rights other than the basic right...to go to court to challenge their long-term captivity;" the Senate Armed Forces Committee released a report finding "senior U.S. officials authorized the use of aggressive interrogation techniques resulting in the abuse of military detainees in U.S. custody;" and finally and a former Air Force interrogator in Iraq has gained wide publicity for speaking out on the ineffectiveness of torture and why it must be stopped.  Check out his interview on the Daily Show below and keep reading after the jump for more on these stories.


Matthew Alexander was a military interrogator in Iraq whose team of interrogators obtained the whereabouts of al-Qaeda in Iraq leader Zarkawi without using torture.  He recently released a book titled, "How to Break a Terrorist: The U.S. Interrogators Who Used Brains, Not Brutality, to Take Down the Deadliest Man in Iraq" and just last week he was interviewed by Jon Stewart about the reasons torture is not an effective, moral or ethical means of interrogation. 

Also in the past week, the Senate Armed Services Committee's Inquiry into the Treatment of Detainees in U.S. Custody was released, providing "most thorough review by Congress to date of the origins of the abuse of prisoners in American military custody."  Even more importantly, the report "explicitly rejects the Bush administration's contention that tough interrogation methods have helped keep the country and its troops safe."  Although much of the report remains classified, a summary is available here.

Last but most definitely not least, on Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court ordered "the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals to reconsider its decision in a case brought by Guantanamo detainees."   The detainees alleged that in addition to suffering physical and psychological torture, they "were harassed while practicing their religion, including forced shaving of their beards, banning or interrupting their prayers, denying them copies of the Koran and prayer mats and throwing a copy of the Koran in a toilet bucket."

The detainees argued "in their lawsuit that the treatment violated the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which provides that the 'government shall not substantially burden a person's exercise of religion.'" The appeals court had ruled against the four detainees in January "saying that neither the Constitution nor a federal law protecting religious freedom gave them the right to sue in American courts."  Since January, however, the Supreme Court ruled in Boumediene v. Bush that "Guantánamo prisoners [have] the right to challenge their detention in federal court" and therefore, the Court has ordered that the case be reconsidered "in light of their holding in [Boumediene]...that detainees have some rights under the Constitution."  

For more on the implications of this ruling, check out the coverage on SCOTUSBlog, and the RACBlog will of course keep you updated on developments in the retrial of this case.  

Small Steps Toward Equality

While we continue to wait for a verdict on the status of Prop 8 in California, over on the east coast we have some glimmers of light on the equality front.

A New Jersey commission appointed by Governor Jon Corzine urged the state to consider legislation allowing full same-sex marriage rights.  This would replace the state's current civil union system which the commission said was ineffective.

Right next door in New York, in accordance with Governor Paterson's directive to recognize out-of-state same-sex marriages, the state will now allow married, same-sex couples to put both parents' names on the birth certificates of newborns.  Meanwhile, New York City is considering changing its birth certificate forms to include same-sex couples outright.  Unfortunately, as you may have heard, Democratic members of the State Assembly and Senate seem to be backing down from their promise of pursuing marriage equality in the next legislative session.

On the non-legislative front, Newsweek ran a cover article earlier this month on religious values and support for same-sex marriage.  After the article hit the newsstands, the magazine received scores of emails, responses, and blog posts attacking the article.  The response was so overwhelming that editors posted an article on their website called "A Religious Reaction to Gay Marriage" that included a number of the responses.

Those opposed to marriage equality do not have a monopoly on values.  However, when mobilized, they can make it seem so.  I encourage you to comment on the article or contact the editorial staff and make your voice heard.

December 12, 2008

Giving Green

'Tis the season to be giving. But what if this year our Chanukah gifts could help the planet in addition to helping putting a smile on the faces of our loved ones? There are plenty of big and small ways to 'green' your gifts and celebrations, and the following are only a few suggestions...
The Coalition on the Environment and Jewish Life Green Gift Guide has ideas for thoughtful and responsible gifts for Chanukah and beyond, with ideas for Jewish and secular holidays throughout the year.

The Natural Resources Defense Council goes 'beyond the basics' with their Great Green Gift Guide, with gift suggestions for everyone from nature lovers to foodies. If you want to make a commitment to protecting wildlife and open spaces this year, NRDC recommends planting a rainforest tree in honor of friends and family members, and the Sierra Club can help you sponsor a piece of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge.

The Treehugger Gift Guide has everything from organic chocolate to composters, and a special page for Chanukah with recycled menorahs and sustainable wood dreidels. You can even get green gift ideas from celebrities like Meryl Streep, whose top product picks are up on the National Geographic Green Guide, which has its own gifts page as well. Other groups recommend simple and affordable gifts like sustainable stationary and fabric gift bags.

The theme is clear: you can promote sustainable living through your holiday gifts, and reduce, reuse, and recycle your way through this Chanukah. Help make a great miracle-the greening of our planet- happen here.

Celebrate a Victory

courtdaylogo.pngIt's easy to look back on the impact of the Bush Administration on the Federal Bench and wonder if the progressive community had any victories. This week especially, we were inundated by reports in the Washington Post about how President Bush reshaped the Appellate Courts and added more white, male, and conservative judges to the entire Federal Bench. But, there is one victory that we have not taken the time to celebrate--the successful blockage of Richard Honkaer's nomination. 

President Bush nominated Mr. Honaker to be a district judge of the United States District Court of the District of Wyoming. In March of 2008, the Union for Reform Judaism, in accordance with the URJ's 2002's resolution, resolved to oppose Mr. Honkaer's nomination and sent a letter to the United States Senate emphatically urging each Senator to oppose the confirmation.  In the words of the letter, "Mr. Honaker's record on religious liberty and reproductive rights raises serious concerns about his ability to be an impartial adjudicator, one who respects stare decisis on relevant cases that will most certainly come before him should he be given a seat on the federal bench." The URJ does not take opposition to a candidate lightly.  Since the adoption of our 2002 resolution, we have opposed only 7 judicial nominees.&

The URJ's concerns about Mr, Honaker were echoed by many organizations within the progressive community and our voices were loud enough to prevent the Judiciary Committee from scheduling a vote on Mr. Honaker's nomination.  As we look at the Federal Bench and decry its significant movement to the right, we can at least breathe one sigh of relief knowing that Mr. Honaker will not be confirmed.  This reality may have been evident weeks ago, but as the 110th Congress comes to an end, we are finally assured.  We can take a moment to celebrate this small victory as we move forward into a new Administration, which we hope will quickly change the landscape of the Federal Bench and make strides toward regaining balance.

December 11, 2008

Executions Declining!

This week, the Death Penalty Information Center (DPIC) released a report finding that in 2008, "the number of executions in U.S. prisons hit a 14-year-low" and continued a "downward trend that began in 2000." The report also found that in 2008, "95% of all executions occurred in the South," 49% of which took place in Texas, and California alone "is spending $138 million per year on a death penalty system...described as 'broken' and 'close to collapse." You can find the full text of the report is on DPIC's website.

 

The one noteworthy caveat to these numbers is that the figures were likely as low as they were because of a "de facto Supreme Court moratorium that put off any capital punishment for the first four months of 2008." On the upside, the Executive Director of DPIC, Richard Dieter, noted "the surge in executions that we expected after [the end of the moratorium] did not happen." And of course, while the declining trend toward zero is great news, our work is far from done. Troy Anthony Davis still awaits a fair trial in Georgia, innocent people sit on death row, and executions continue to occur in appalling numbers.

GLBT Rights in Iowa: A Play-by-Play

Sally Frank is a member of Women of Reform Judaism and the Commission on Social Action.

The marriage equality case was argued this week before the Iowa Supreme Court, and I thought you might be interested to hear how the argument went. There were several unusual features. First, the argument was simulcast on the Web in video as well as audio. I believe that it is still available. Second, usually the Court gives 10 minutes to each side for argument and holds the parties to the limits. Monday morning, each side was given 30 minutes for argument and the County ten additional minutes for rebuttal. All sides took longer, though, with the argument lasting one hour and 45 minutes. Third, there was far more discussion of various precedents from Iowa, the US Supreme Court, and other states than in the usual argument. Fourth, the courtroom was packed.

Polk County (Des Moines' county) was on the other side of the case. The state's attorney general did not choose to come in to the case to defend Iowa's DOMA statute (Defense of Marriage Act). The County's argument centered on two points: One was that history and custom limits marriage to be between a man and a woman and therefore there was no discrimination in the statute; second, that marriage is for procreation. When questioned about whether infertile people could be banned from marriage, he admitted they could not but then could not explain why that didn't hurt his argument. He also argued that the optimum situation for a child is to have a father and mother and recognizing gay marriage would be the state saying that knowing one's parents is unimportant. Because same sex couples have children by other means, both biological parents are not part of the child's life. The Justices asked questions about the fact that pedophiles can get married even though they would not be optimum parents. They also pointed out that reproductive technology allows heterosexual couples to have children even if they are not the biological parents of the children.

The lawyer for the Plaintiffs' (six couples seeking marriage) argued that there was no rational basis for the statute. He argued that history and tradition do not provide a satisfactory basis, even using rational basis analysis. He had a little trouble distinguishing his argument that marriage was a fundamental right that could not be limited to heterosexuals from the question of polygamists also having a fundamental right to marry. At one point though, he pointed out that no other Iowa laws that deal with marriage in any way would need to be changed if same sex couples were allowed to marry. This would not be the case with polygamy. There was a fair amount of discussion over whether the proper test for review was rational basis, heightened scrutiny, or compelling state interest. The Plaintiff's lawyer argued that there was not even a rational basis for the law. He ended his argument very powerfully: One of the Justices asked about civil union as a solution, and the lawyer pointed to the daughter of two of the plaintiffs, saying she was hurt that her two moms weren't married. He noted that the only reason to call it something other than marriage was to say that same-sex couples did not deserve marriage, then he quoted from Brown v. Board of Education about the harms that separate status cause.

The County's rebuttal focused again on procreation and tradition. He mentioned at one point that destroying marriage would not help children but was otherwise fairly measured in his arguments. The Iowa Supreme Court has a history of being in the vanguard of civil rights. It banned segregated schools in the 1800's and upheld criminal penalties for public accommodations race discrimination in the 1940's. The first published opinion of the Court rejected the notion that a fugitive slave was someone's property. We can only hope that it will follow this tradition when it reaches a ruling in this case.

Reproductive Health for Hanukkah?

Jon Stewart's riff on Planned Parenthood of Indiana's gift cards is pretty hilarious, but the reality is that an increasingly large percentage of women cannot afford the reproductive health services they need.


According to a Kaiser Family Foundation and Urban Institute study, 19% of women are without health insurance, and women are the most vulnerable population for losing their insurance. Women without insurance are more likely to delay or go without important preventive care such as mammograms and Pap tests. With the current economic crisis and rising costs of health care in general, women are likely to turn to low-cost clinics like Planned Parenthood for their annual gynecological exams and other common reproductive health needs. Yes, the gift cards can be used for abortions, STI/HIV testing, and contraceptives, but their foremost purpose is for preventive care. 

While the gift cards are available to purchase and give to anyone, Planned Parenthood of Indiana offers the option of donating your gift card to patients in need. So this Hanukkah, consider giving someone the gift of reproductive health!

December 10, 2008

Observing Human Rights Day

This week marks the 60th anniversary of the signing of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Around the world governments, faith groups and organizations will hold events celebrating, studying, and helping to realize the principles laid out in the declaration. Here are a few ideas to help you with your own observation of Human Rights Day and making your own contributions to the lasting work for human rights in our world.

Now is the Time for Tzedakah

As the holiday season grows nearer, families across the country are warning their children that this year, money will be too tight for the same sort of extravagant gifts that often accompany both Christmas and Chanukah. This year's, Santa's got to watch his wallet, too, and "eight crazy nights" may not translate into crazy-big gifts.

But in an op-ed in the Forward last week, Leonard Fein, founder of Mazon, explains why now, more than ever, Americans should be opening their wallets this holiday season - not for big toys or extravagant vacations but for tzedakah and providing help to those who need it most. He writes,
The Union for Reform Judaism has launched a campaign entitled "Nothing But Nets," an effort to provide insecticide-treated bed nets to the impoverished in Africa. Such bed nets, which cost $10 each, are the surest defense against malaria, which is spread by mosquitoes and which in 2006 killed 881,000 people, most of them children younger than 5 in sub-Saharan Africa.

The Nakivale refugee camp in Uganda, "home" to some 18,000 people, including growing numbers of Congolese refugees, is infested with mosquitoes, so malaria is easily spread -- but the refugees can't afford mosquito nets and bedding. The Reform movement campaign plans to provide every person in the Nakivale camp a proper bed net, and then to move on to other locations. It has set a goal of $500,000, enough to distribute 50,000 nets. Why not make a point, during Hanukkah, of gathering the family just after the candle-lighting to make an online contribution to Nothing But Nets? Just click on to www.urj.org/nets and send $10 -- or, better yet, $18. (It can be such a compelling ritual that you might want to send $10 a night on each of the eight nights.) The kids at Nakivale can't wait until the recession's over and things are back to "normal."
I'm not saying that we're not hurting, too. We are. But as Fein says in his closing lines, "It's not easy, I know. I actually was trying to figure out where I could cut my giving this year before I realized that I'd rather gamble with my future solvency than with other people's lives. There is a reason, after all, we do not call it charity but tzedakah -- righteousness."

December 8, 2008

Looking Forward: WRJ in the New Year



Carolyn Kunin is Director of Programming and Advocacy for Women of Reform Judaism.

As the deepening crisis looms over our economy, Women of Reform Judaism considers an emergency stimulus package, to respond to the urgent needs of impoverished Americans while boosting the economy, a first priority for the new administration and the 111th Congress. As reported by the Coalition on Human Needs, this should include increased funding for nutrition and home energy assistance, child care and Head Start, and state-run health care programs, such as Medicaid and the State Children's Health Insurance Program. Creation of new jobs directed towards rebuilding and greening the infrastructure and helping families to stay in their homes should be an integral part of the emergency stimulus package.

Almost exponentially rising health care costs with over 45 million uninsured Americans makes the need for health care reform to cover all Americans an urgent priority, which we urge the 111th Congress and the new administration to begin addressing immediately. WRJ also considers increased funding for comprehensive sexuality education an additional priority, which may be relatively cost neutral because of the need to defund abstinence-only programs, which do not work.

WRJ considers rapid passage and signing of the following bills an important priority: 

Happily, most of the legislative priorities discussed above are among the policies discussed on the President-elect Barack Obama transition Web site, Change.gov. WRJ looks forward to speaking up for our priorities with the new administration and Congress.

December 5, 2008

Make A Great Miracle Happen There

Over Chanukkah, we all look for thoughtful, useful and interesting gifts for our family and friends. Amid the ads for watches, sweaters and digital cameras this winter, you might notice an ad for another kind of gift. A bed net. As part of our goal to deliver 50,000 nets abroad, the Union for Reform Judaism will be advertising Nothing But Nets in Jewish media around the country this winter.

While you may not know anyone who wants their bed covered in insecticide-treated mesh, there are people abroad to whom this gift won't simply be nice and thoughtful, but life-saving. A child dies from malaria every 30 seconds, and the use of a bed net can reduce disease transmission by up to 90%. The bed nets donated through the Union for Reform Judaism's Nothing But Nets initiative will go straight to refugees of conflict in Africa-one of the populations most vulnerable to malaria. It takes only $10 to send a net.

And while your friends and family won't receive a bed net themselves, they will get the gift of leaning how small efforts at home can change lives far away. They will get a broader understanding of and connection to the world around them. They will get the chance to teach their children about issues facing children abroad. They will get an appreciation of the goodness in their lives. And most of all, they get to take part in one of the most important and amazing things in the world-saving someone else's life.

As Rabbi David Saperstein, director of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism, noted yesterday (on a call promoting ONE Sabbath, a great way to extend your Nothing But Nets activism,) "When you buy one net for $10, you are saving a life. That is a very rare thing to do. When you feed someone for $10 you will need to do it again. When you buy one net, it stays there."

This winter, due to the efforts of congregations, B'nai mitzvah students and others, the first shipment of bed nets will be delivered to the Nakivale refugee camp in Uganda, providing malaria protection for the entire camp.

We are halfway to our goal of delivering 50,000 bed nets. Inspire your friends and family with the gift of saving a life this Chanukkah. Give them each a donation to Nothing But Nets. Ask them to give the same to you. Have a net-giving party for your whole family! Make a great miracle happen there.

December 4, 2008

Equia v. State of Texas

courtdaylogo.pngCentral to the abortion debate is the concern around the point at which a human life begins. Anti-choice advocates from the Religious Right often support their position by defining an unborn fetus as a "person," giving it the same moral value as an adult human being. Jewish teachings, on the other hand, supports the view that, although an unborn fetus is precious and needs protection, the life of the mother is paramount; an unborn fetus is a potential life, and higher value ought to be placed on existing life.

Equia v. State of Texas, a recent court case in Texas, highlights this conflict. Jacob Equia was convicted of murdering a woman and her unborn child, and a Texas appellate court rejected his constitutional challenge to the Texas statute that defines an unborn child as a "person" for purposes of the capital murder statute. Equia argued that the statute violates the Establishment Clause of the U.S. Constitution and Art. I, Sec. 6 
of the Texas Constitution, which bars giving preference to any religion.

The Texas appellate court held that "a statute is not automatically rendered unconstitutional simply because it advances ideals that harmonize with religious ideals," and concluded that: "the State has a legitimate secular interest in protecting mothers and their unborn children throughout the mother's pregnancy."

While the court may have rightly assessed the religious content of the statute, we must be wary of any law that defines when a human life begins. If killing a pregnant woman deserves two counts of murder, it is a small ideological leap to hold an abortion as murder. I find it appalling that the court suggested such a law is needed to "protect mothers and their unborn children." The State can adequately meet this "secular interest" without defining the fetus as a person by punishing any unwanted injury to a fetus as assault (or any other lesser offense). 

Compassion not Demagoguery

FredGuttman.jpgRabbi Fred Guttman is the rabbi at Temple Emanuel in Greensboro, N.C. and a member of the Commission on Social Action. This post is adapted from his October 17, 2008 sermon.

Hospitality to strangers is a fundamental Jewish value and is found 39 times in first five books of the Bible alone, more than any other single commandment. Clearly in North Carolina, the strangers in our midst are the illegal immigrants. Most of us have recently seen political advertisements which seem to target illegal immigration as the source of all of society's ills.

Recently, I asked one of the candidates who was visiting Temple Emanuel about this issue. The only response was to say that a detention center should be built in North Carolina and that land should be given by the state to the federal government to build such a center. While the candidate certainly did not mean to be insensitive, I found that saying the words "detention center and illegal immigration" in a Jewish synagogue was jarring. Clearly given the history of the Jewish people, such language recalls many images which the candidate did not mean to convey.

No one knows the exact number of illegal immigrants that are in North Carolina. We are told that our overcrowded jails are filled with them. Often, our jails are full to a large extent because of our inability to do anything sensible on this issue, not necessarily because illegal immigrants have committed serious or violent crimes. According to Jewish law, one is forbidden to pass a law which is unenforceable or unreasonable. So for example, a law that would say that all 11,000,000 illegal immigrants should be deported and apply for legal entry would be such a law.

All too often we hear Jews and others say, "Well, our grandparents came to this country legally. Why shouldn't they?" My answer to this is twofold. First, many of our grandparents who did not make it into this country would have loved to have come here illegally, especially prior to and during the period of the Nazi Holocaust. Such immigration would have saved their lives. Second, such a statement ignores the facts on the ground, namely, that tens of thousands of illegal immigrants live in North Carolina and do so solely because they want a better life for themselves and their children.

I often hear that illegal immigrants are a burden to state and federal revenues. But consider this: Many illegal immigrants are hired by companies and give false social security numbers. Their employers pay withholding and FICA taxes for them. They rent apartments whose landlords pay property taxes and like you and me, they pay sales tax on goods purchased. They are not eligible for Social Security benefits but pay into the system. It can take up from a year or two for the Social Security administration to inform the employer of a mismatch. For the most part, illegal immigration is financially neutral or even profitable to our governmental agencies.

The situation, however, which makes the least amount of sense, is the current effort to deny illegal immigrants drivers' licenses. Illegal immigrants will still drive, with or without a license and we would have no way of knowing whether or not these drivers would know the basic laws, or have bad eyesight. This endangers us all.

So what is the solution to this mess? The solution is first to stop "demagogueing" the problem. Many refer to illegal immigrants as "illegal aliens." The word "alien" is far more hostile and frightening than "immigrant." The history of the Jewish people is such that all too often we were treated as aliens and persecuted or even killed because of it.

Second, we desperately need what is called Comprehensive Immigration Reform. Basically this is what President Bush called for when he advocated:
  1. Tightening Border Security
  2. A way for those who are here to enter into a program of earned citizenship without having to return to their former countries, and
  3. A guest worker program.
Such an approach would recognize and respond to the reality that approximately 11 million undocumented individuals currently reside in the United States.

We are living in a highly charged environment concerning this issue and personally I am afraid that without some sort of comprehensive reform of immigration, Americans will begin to scapegoat immigrants for our economic problems, and society as a whole could suffer and could become cruel toward them. As Americans, let us not forget that when our grandparents or great grandparents came to Ellis Island, they passed the Statue of Liberty whose inscription written by Emma Lazurus reads "Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free."

May we have the wisdom to ask our elected representatives the difficult questions on this issue. May we have compassion toward those whose only crime has been to better their lives and those of their children, for they are truly the "poor and huddled masses yearning to breathe free."

As Climate Talks Convene, Who Will Take the Lead?

This week, hundreds of world leaders gather in Poznan, Poland to discuss the ongoing global response to the imminent threat of climate change at the UN Climate Change Conference.  The meeting will set the stage for next year's Conference in Copenhagen, Denmark, where the successor treaty to the Kyoto Protocol will be drafted. Poznan presents yet another critical opportunity for the U.S. to step up to the plate on climate issues and make amends for our failure to take a meaningful role in past international negotiations. As a global superpower and the historic leader in CO2 emissions, we have responsibility to come to the table prepared to act.

The good news is that Senator Kerry (D-MA), incoming Chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, will lead the U.S. delegation to Poznan, joined by Senator Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) and others. Kerry's decision to make the trek to Poland is critical because the Foreign Relations Committee will be the first to pour over any international treaties that come out of Copenhagen. As Kerry and others outside the Committees that typically address environment issues (Energy and Commerce in the House, Environment and Public Works in the Senate) become active on climate and energy, the opportunity expands for robust debate in Washington, and U.S. leadership on this issue.

Less encouraging is the decision of the Obama transition team not to send anyone to Poland, despite repeated promises to make this a priority issue when the President-elect takes office in January. Disappointing to me, on a personal level, is the lack of Jewish presence at the Conference; while several Christian denominations and other faith groups sent representatives to monitor the negotiations and hold faith events on climate, there is no formal Jewish participation in the event. The Jewish voice on climate is steadily becoming louder and more articulate but we as a community, like our nation as a whole, are still far from leaders on this issue.

While no new treaties are expected to emerge by the time the conference closes next week, Poznan is a critical step along the path to global action to confront the climate crisis. Without serious U.S. engagement and leadership, the possibilities for a meaningful global response to climate change are severely limited. And without participating in these conferences, our Jewish voice on this issue will be dampened as well.  Politicians and faith leaders alike deserve praise for braving the cold and making the trip, and leaders who are not participating need to hear from their constituents (read: all of us!), urging them to keep climate change in the forefront.

December 3, 2008

Getting Serious about Preventing WMD Terrorism

The Commission on the Prevention of WMD Proliferation and Terrorism, led by former Sens. Bob Graham of Florida and Jim Talent of Missouri, announced at a press conference earlier today the findings of their bipartisan panel. In a stark warning to the United States and the world, the commission found that "unless the world community acts decisively and with great urgency, it is more likely than not that a weapon of mass destruction will be used in a terrorist attack somewhere in the world by the end of 2013."

The panel's report makes clear the urgency of nonproliferation efforts, warning that "the more proliferation that occurs, the greater the risk of additional proliferation, as nations that have to this point declined to acquire nuclear weapons will believe it necessary to counter their neighbors who have developed those capabilities." As this "increases the prospect that these weapons will be poorly secured and thus may be stolen by terrorists", the commission made a number of recommendations about addressing this threat.

The Boston Globe reports that President-elect Obama is set to heed the eighth recommendation of the commission by designating a White House principal advisor for WMD proliferation and terrorism.

President-elect Obama's administration can help prevent nuclear terrorism by taking seriously as well the recommendation to "work internationally toward strengthening the nonproliferation regime, reaffirming the vision of a world free of nuclear weapons." Only by doing so can we truly hope to turn back the tide against proliferation, prevent Iran and other dangerous regimes and terrorist groups from obtaining nuclear weapons, and ensure the instability and terrorism emanating from Pakistan do not involve even deadlier weapons.

The Reform Movement has long called for the world to work together to prevent the massive destruction wrought by the use of nuclear weapons by achieving total nuclear disarmament. While the White House must step up its efforts, we must also get involved in the effort to create a safer world free of nuclear dangers.

One way to get involved with the work to create a safer, nuclear weapons free world is to take action through our partner, the Campaign for a Nuclear Weapons Free World.

Indeed, as the report's final recommendation states, "citizens should hold their governments accountable." Let's do so and make sure our government is doing everything possible to keep us safe by eliminating the threat of nuclear weapons from the earth.

Intelligence or Divine Randomness?

Thanks to the Texas Board of Education, Intelligent Design and Evolution have reappeared on the forefront of public debate. Recently, Reform Rabbis testified in front of the Board of Education on the importance of keeping religion from the classroom and Rabbi Ana Bonnheim posted on the RACBlog about that experience.

Since then, there have been interesting posts on, in addition to the RACBlog, AU's The Wall of SeparationReligionClause, and WiredScience.  On salon.com, David M. White posted an interesting article called "Intelligent Design Rules Out God's Sovereignty Over Chance," in which he explains how ID is not only bad science, but is also faulty theology.  On Monday, the Houston Chronicle ran a fantastic op-ed by Lisa Falkenberg decrying the required teaching in states like Texas of the "strengths and weaknesses" of scientific theories (i.e. evolution).  She calls it "a new buzz phrase that's replaced 'creation science' and 'intelligent design,' and other science curriculum labels that incorporate teachings of faith" and she is absolutely right.

So please, read up, check out the RAC's resources on Intelligent Design and Evolution, including the URJ and CCAR Resolutions that state our opposition to teaching ID in schools, and get ready to help us fight this fight when the time comes! To quote Falkenberg: "True scientific debate is healthy. So are questions. But injecting doubt in curriculum for the sake of ideological agenda will harm our students and our state."

December 2, 2008

Brickner Fellows Retreat A Success!



Rosalind Gold is Program Director of the Rabbi Balfour Brickner Rabbinic Seminar and Fellow Program.

Mid-November saw the first gathering of this year's Brickner Fellows. The Rabbi Balfour Brickner Rabbinic Seminar and Fellow Program, sponsored jointly by the RAC and CLAL (the National Jewish Center for Leadership and Learning) and funded through a generous endowment by Mr. Al Engelberg, is part of a two-year commitment by a group of rabbis to study and learn together and to gain the tools necessary to do effective, honest social justice advocacy. 

The goal of the Brickner program is to empower rabbis from across denominational lines to discern core Jewish values and to approach Jewish texts freed of pre-conceived notions of what the text means - to "de-automate" as our teachers from CLAL have termed it. This approach to study involves active listening, and developing the ability to understand and even empathize with positions other than our own. Being open to new possibilities in a text, the rabbis can then become more effective social activists - being able to articulate Jewish values with integrity, and engage in constructive dialogue and debate with those who stand on opposite sides of an issue, capable of influencing social policy.

The retreat, held at Capital Camps in Pennsylvania, followed an earlier seminar held in Washington, where more than 30 rabbis from the Reform, Conservative, and Reconstructionist movements gathered to study Jewish texts on various topics of social concern, learning from Rabbis Irwin Kula and Tsvi Blanchard of CLAL, Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson of the American Jewish University, Rabbi Lew Barth of the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion, Rabbis Nina Beth Cardin and Fred Scherlinder Dobb of COEJL (the Coalition on the Environment and Jewish Life), Rabbi Marla Feldman, Director of the URJ Commission on Social Action, Rabbi Jonah Pesner of Just Congregations, and the RAC's own Rabbi David Saperstein, Rabbi Michael Namath, and Mark Pelavin. From this original group, a cohort of 11 rabbis was chosen to become Brickner Fellows, participating in the retreat and in upcoming distance learning calls. Rabbi Tsvi Blanchard, CLAL's Director of Organizational Development, led the 5-day retreat, assisted by Rabbi Michael Namath, Program Director at the RAC and Rabbi Rosalind Gold, Coordinator of the Brickner programs.

The 11 Brickner Fellows will "meet" by conference call for continued study and discussion over the coming months, and meet face-to-face for study and discussion during the Consultation on Conscience in April.

Preview: Fitzgerald v Barnstable

Bob Sedler is a Distinguished Professor of Law at Wayne State University Law School and a member of the URJ's Commission on Social Action.  All views expressed are his own.

courtdaylogo.pngThis case arises out of an unfortunate situation of peer-on-peer sexual harassment at the elementary school level, involving a third grade boy and a kindergarten girl. When the girl's parents complained to the school authorities, they investigated the matter. They decided not to take disciplinary action against the boy, and proposed that the girl ride a different bus. Her parents rejected this suggestion and countered with other proposals that the school authorities rejected. There were no further incidents aboard the bus.

The girl's parents brought a federal court suit against the school officials. The suit alleged that the actions and inactions of the school authorities with respect to the peer-on-peer sexual harassment constituted gender discrimination in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment's equal protection clause and also violated Title IX of the Education Act Amendments of 1972. The constitutional claim was brought under the federal civil rights act of 1871 (the Ku Klux Klan Act), 42 U.S. C. sec. 1983, which imposes liability against any person who, acting under color of state law, violates rights guaranteed by the Constitution or laws of the United States. Title IX provides that, "[n]o person . . . shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance," and authorizes claims against school districts receiving federal funds.


The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (which covers Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Maine, Rhode Island, and Puerto Rico) held that by the enactment of Title IX, Congress intended to preclude the use of 42 U.S.C. 1983 to present claims of unconstitutional gender discrimination in schools. (The Court also held that the actions of the school authorities in dealing with the matter were not violative of Title IX, and that part of its decision was not appealed to the Supreme Court). The result of this decision is that when there is a claim of unconstitutional gender discrimination in the schools, the claim must be asserted against the school district in accordance with the provisions of Title IX instead of as a constitutional claim against the school district and against school officials under 42 U.S.C. sec. 1983.


The question is one of Congressional intent. When Congress enacted Title IX, did it thereby intend to preclude the use of 42 U.S.C. sec. 1983 to present claims of unconstitutional gender discrimination in schools? It may be noted that Title IX did not expressly bar the use of section 1983 to present such claims. Rather the Court held that Title IX's remedial scheme is sufficiently comprehensive as to demonstrate Congress's intent to limit the available remedies to those provided by Title IX itself. The parents contend that Title IX's remedial scheme is not sufficiently comprehensive to demonstrate such intent, primarily because the primary means of enforcing the statute is the withholding of federal funds, which is rarely used. They also argue that Title IX does not provide a remedy against school officials and so will not deter them from engaging in unconstitutional discrimination.
Since the case involves a question of statutory interpretation, Congress can revisit the matter and make its intention clear - either way - after the Court decides the case.

December 1, 2008

Another Step for Stem Cells

This holiday season, Claudia Castillo will have something extra to be thankful for- a functioning windpipe- thanks to the miracle of stem cell research. Castillo has been breathing easier since an operation performed in June by a team of French doctors using stem cells drawn from her own bone marrow to line a tracheal passage transplanted from a donor. While it is still too early to call the procedure a definite success, so far Castillo is doing well and her body is accepting the tracheal transfer, due in part to the stem cells used in the procedure.
Here in the U.S. we can also celebrate stem cells this year, following a ballot measure to decriminalize and fund such research that passed (by a slim majority) in Michigan in November. The CureMichigan proposal allows fertility clinics to donate for research embryos that would otherwise be discarded, and lets researchers create embryonic stem cell cultures to study disease. Several Reform Rabbis and other Jewish community members worked in support of the proposal, backed by strong URJ policy supporting stem cell research.

Many doctors and research scientists believe that stem cells may hold the key to treating and potentially curing diseases like Alzheimer's and Parkinson's, in addition to their tremendous value for tissue and organ transplants.

Innovations like the windpipe transplant serve as a constant reminder of the potential of stem cells to relieve human suffering and allow so many men, women, and children to live longer, healthier lives. However, these cures will never emerge if primary research, and the funding for it, is curtailed by federal and state laws limiting work with both adult and embryonic stem cells. The Reform Movement has long been an outspoken supporter of stem cell research, consistent with one of our core Jewish values: pikuach nefesh, the obligation to save a life. As we continue to hear these amazing stories, let us not forget all the behind-the-scenes work that enables such breakthroughs, including the public policy that is so critical to shaping our priorities and opportunities as a nation.

Feed Subscription