Hard of Hearing, but not of Living Jewishly

I’m 3 years old and moderately hard of hearing, but still able to hear my mom sing Shalom Aleichem to me to get me to sleep. I’m in a nursery school affiliated with a Reform synagogue in Baltimore, singing along to “We give thanks to God for bread” and listening for hours to the Home Start tapes the old Baltimore Board of Jewish Education put together for Jewish families in the area. Everything is going well until one morning I wake up completely deaf. I’m 5 years old and now profoundly deaf instead of just hard of hearing. Now what?  Will I still be able to go to Hebrew School, have a bat mitzvah down the line, my parents wonder? Meanwhile, I’m upset with God and ask my mother, “Why did God make me deaf?

Rachel Dubin leads a Hanukkah candle lighting service on a cruise ship. Photo courtesy of Rachel.

It has now been 30 years since I lost all my residual hearing. I have never let my deafness stop me from anything, even from being Jewish. My parents made sure I learned to speak, read, and write Hebrew and reinforced at home what I learned in Hebrew School at our synagogue. They encouraged me to recite the Shabbat blessings at our Friday night dinners and participate in Shabbat and holiday services at synagogue. When it came time for my Bat Mitzvah, there was no question that I would chant from the Torah and lead the congregation in prayer, from the Yotzer straight through to Ein Keloheinu, just like my hearing peers. As it turned out, my Bat Mitzvah was on Simchat Torah…. which meant I had two Torah portions to learn to chant, instead of the usual single portion! That would be daunting for any 13-year-old, much less a deaf one with a single hearing aid, but I met the challenge, with the help of my rabbis and the local Bar/Bat mitzvah tutor. Almost 25 years later, it remains one of my proudest achievements.

As a teenager, I joined MAFTY, now NFTY-MAR; while it could be difficult socially for me at times and I had trouble following along with what was being said in group discussions, I still managed to make friends, learn more about Judaism, sing my heart out in song sessions, be moved by Shabbat services, and even be Social Action Vice President of my Temple Youth Group. In college, I helped found a KESHER chapter and compiled and led NFTY-style Shabbat services. As a graduate student with a newly activated cochlear implant, I found myself leading about 100 undergrads in a song session after Shabbat dinner at the local Hillel one night. As an adult, I’ve led services at a local chavurah I belong to, and even on a cruise ship in the Mediterranean. Let me tell you: Leading a standing-room-only library full of Australian, British, and American Jews in a Reform-style Shabbat service, along with a Chanukah candle lighting, while sailing out of Egypt (talk about the Exodus from Mitzrayim!) en route to Italy is a really, really surreal and amazing experience. My mother, who thought I would grow up to be a rabbi, would have been proud.

I am truly blessed and proud to be part of such an inclusive Jewish community, with wonderful, caring clergy, that has enabled me to learn about and practice my religion despite my profound hearing loss. However, it has not been without its difficulties, and we as a Jewish community still have a long way to go. For example, I have had to fight for oral interpreters to be provided at synagogue-sponsored lectures and at Jewish adult-education classes, and many times my requests have been denied. Area synagogues have not been accessible – one has a very dark sanctuary with poor acoustics, which makes it difficult to see or hear the rabbi and cantor; another has a sanctuary that echoes and does not appear to have a telecoil loop, which makes it impossible to hear voices over the microphone without interference from the background noise.

On this first Deaf and Hard of Hearing Awareness Shabbat, I hope we will all heed the words of Leviticus 19:14, “Do not curse the deaf or put a stumbling block in front of the blind.” Let us all – rabbis, cantors, lay leaders, congregants, educators, and so forth – take steps toward creating a more inclusive community by ensuring there is funding to provide oral or sign language interpreters; providing interpreters upon request; improving synagogue lighting; installing in our sanctuaries telecoil loops and/or modern assistive listening devices that can be utilized by hearing aids and cochlear implants alike; and, most importantly, being supportive of our deaf and hard-of-hearing children and adults and being understanding of their communication needs.  As the Torah teaches, we are all created b’tselem Elohim, in God’s image.

Rachel Dubin lives in Washington, D.C., and is a member of Baltimore Hebrew Congregation.

Twitter Digg Delicious Stumbleupon Technorati Facebook Email

About Guest

We welcome guest submissions to the RACblog. All guest posts are the opinions of the author, and do not necessarily represent the policies of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism.

5 Responses to “Hard of Hearing, but not of Living Jewishly”

  1. If Rachel had wanted to be a rabbi, she would have accomplished it and been successful. She’s not asking people to go through years of training to learn to sign. She’s just asking people to be thoughtful. BTW oral interpreters mouth the words where their lips can be easily read.

  2. Rachel, we are all so proud of you. Watching you grow up and being part of the adult community has been amazing. You have accomplished everything you have set out to do.
    I know your mother is in her own way very proud and of course your father is.
    our love, elyce and (one of your rabbi’s) aryeh

  3. Well, if you want to be accurate, it’s ISL – Israeli Sign Language. And, good luck to the people at the Hebrew Seminary of the Deaf. Very few have completed the program, and even fewer have paying jobs as rabbis. The one deaf female rabbi I’ve seen from there isn’t even able to read from a Torah scroll. If you want to be a rabbi, go to a real rabbinic school like HUC or JTS or the Recon Seminary. If you want to learn how to sign, go to a community college and take some classes, and mix with the deaf community. But if you read her story carefully, you’ll see that Rachel doesn’t sign at all.

  4. What about clergy with the ability to sign? Can that be a priority, too? No fewer than two members of my congregation in Chicago are enrolled at the Hebrew Seminary of the Deaf (www.hebrewseminarydeaf.org, nearby in Skokie, IL) seeking rabbinic ordination. I’m actually considering the program, too. Rabbis of all stripes learn ancient and modern Hebrew and ancient Aramaic (vocalized and (non-vocalized). So, nu? Why not ASL and HSL, too?


  1. Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing in the Pews: A Parent’s Perspective :: Fresh Updates from RAC - May 4, 2012

    […] the accessibility needs of the deaf and hard-of-hearing. As a parent of a profoundly deaf daughter, Rachel, I have seen the changes in my own congregation, which has made it comfortable for her to […]

Leave a Reply