RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    The Muslim-Jewish Tipping Point - Full Post
    July 30, 2008
    Social Action | The Future (5 comments)

    By Eboo Patel
    (First posted on Newsweek/Washington Post's On Faith)
    "Nobody believes you guys actually exist," I said to the group I was eating dinner with.

    I was sitting with the North American Board of Reform Judaism's youth movement (called NFTY) at their summer leadership camp, Kutz.

    These five teenagers were responsible for leading programming for thousands of young Reform Jews across the country. This year's study theme: Muslim-Jewish Relations. And these young leaders couldn't be more excited it.

    I do interfaith work with young people for a living, and even I was taken aback by their enthusiasm.

    "Tell me why this is so important to you?" I asked. The reasons spilled forth:

    "Making new friends."

    "Making peace."

    "Sharing lessons on what it means to be religious in a secular society."

    Susan Sontag once wrote, "Whatever is happening, something else is always going on." While newspaper headlines are dominated by stories of hatred and violence between Jews and Muslims, there is a quiet revolution taking place off the radar screen.

    Last year witnessed an historic warming in Muslim-Jewish relations in America. Rabbi Eric Yoffie, President of the Union for Reform Judaism (the largest Jewish denomination in America, with 1.5 million members and 900 congregations), gave a well-received keynote presentation at the annual convention of the Islamic Society of North America (ISNA).

    In the recent issue of Reform Judaism, the movement's magazine, Yoffie writes: "The time has come to engage in dialogue with our Muslim neighbors and to educate ourselves about Islam."

    Professor Ingrid Mattson, the President of ISNA (an umbrella body for the millions of American Muslims) responded in kind by traveling to the URJ Convention and making these remarks:

    "Muslims have instinctively turned to the example of Jews in America to understand how to deal with the challenges we face as religious minorities whether these challenges involve securing the right to religious accommodation in public institutions, or dealing with workplace discrimination. At the same time, I believe that the Jewish community will also benefit from having Muslim partners in the struggle to uphold the constitutional separation of church and state, to promote civil liberties, to extend religious accommodation to minorities and to counter prejudice and hatred."

    There are other Muslim-Jewish efforts afoot. Organizations like Seeds of Peace, Search for Common Ground, Children of Abraham and Abraham's Vision, have been nurturing this revolution for years. Rabbi Marc Schneier's Foundation for Ethnic Understanding, which played a profound role in advancing black-Jewish dialogue with Russell Simmons, is focusing now on Muslim-Jewish issues.

    We might actually be at a tipping point on this seemingly impossible issue.

    And I have a hunch that it's young Muslims and Jews, just like the ones I met at the Kutz camp, who are going to push this thing over the edge.

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    Jan said:

    Lovely to read this article of youth and hope, but will Kutz make any difference in the West Bank or Gaza, where Palestinians are merclessly being driven out?

    Jay Padgug said:

    Responding to Jan's brief comment. I fear that Jan is unfortunately an apologist for the Palestinians. I don't want to make this a discussion of the Israeli-Arab issue, but Jan shows little empathy for her people in Israel and little understanding of the entire context.

    I hope that Kutz is the forerunner of increasing dialogue and understanding --- and that improved Jewish-Muslim relations here might ultimately have some impact on relations among people in the Middle East, including between Israel and the Palestinians.

    Lois Swartz said:

    Dear Jay,

    I share Jan's viewpoint and don't consider myself as an apologist for bad behavior of Palestinians. My discomfort with many Jews is that we we accept Israel's numerous human rights abuses as right and necessary for Israel's preservation. The opposite is true. What are we preserving of Judaism and Jewish values when we support the expansion of settlements continuing house demolition and continual appropriation of internationally recognized borders. The best aquifer in Israel is under Qualquilya which is totally surrounded by the barrier. How do we brag "Democracy" when the High Court that almost a year ago ruled the army had confiscated too much land from B'lin which has had three years of non-violent demonstration. But the ultimate decision is up to the army which will not move its army roads and electrified fence. If this were South America such behavior would be called a military junta. My wide reading of Schlaim and many other scholars and my visit to Israel and the West Bank and sponsorship of the various Palestinian/Israeli peace groups like Combatants for Peace and Break the Silence who travel visit the US tells me that we have much to do in breaking the silence in the American Jewish Community and creating our Occupation Heshbon H'Nefesh, soul searching . Good if it could happen before this New Year, but I don't expect it to happen. As a committed syagogue Jew and a Middle East peace activist we have a long way to go from Jewish/Muslim 101. We must get real and open our eyes not justs to our suffering but the suffering caused by 40 years of Occcupation and the enabling of American Jews.
    LOis Swartz, Bubbes and Zaydes (Grandparents) for Peace in the Middle East.

    Jake said:

    Kutz is not being posited as "the" solution to the Middle East peace process, but as a leadership training initiative for the young Jews who will play a major part, Mr. Patel and I both hope. It is not the only one, as he pointed out.

    Jan seems to be unfamiliar with Seeds of Peace, which Patel mentions, which brings together not only Jewish and Arab-Americans, but Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs, as well as Palestinians from Ramallah and Gaza (and Greeks and Cypriots, Irish Catholics and Protestants...the list goes on). I had the pleasure of working with several Palestinian graduates of the program in college, and I think that they do a pretty damn good job of nurturing future leaders.

    Jake B said:

    I was at Kutz, and I heard Mr. Patel speak. I attended the programming on interfaith relations, and it was not only meaningful to me, but engaging. The point of this specific issue at Kutz (and this is one of many) is to focus on the starting of a dialogue between young Jews and young Muslims. There was a specific emphasis on doing this through incorporating community service and tikkun olam which are concepts that both religions embrace and value. There is a school of thought that says to ignore the conflict and differences at first, and rather focus on our similarities. The discussion of differences will come later. It is important to first create not just an open discussion, but a relationship with our Muslim counterparts. The Palestinian conflict has nothing to do with the issue at hand. It is one small tree in a forest of problems (see media portrayal of the Jewish-Muslim relationship, overall hatred and bigotry, and utter ignorance of facts). It is important to focus on the forest. We should not get caught up in small trees which may ultimately stall our efforts, and do more harm than good. Try to focus on the harmony that exists between our religions, and you will see less and less discord. This is still an inchoate project...give it a chance to take flight.

    Post a comment