RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    "You wouldn't be voting for Obama today if Andy Goodman hadn't gone to Mississippi "
    November 5, 2008
    Community | Social Action (5 comments)

    (First posted on the RACblog)
    The following is an e-mail letter from Doug Mishkin to his daughter Arielle and their very close friend Melanie Anenberg. Doug, a lawyer with the Washington Office of Patton Boggs, is a long time activist who developed a close friendship with Carolyn Goodman, mother of slain Civil Rights worker Andrew Goodman. 

    Arielle and Melanie:

    I woke up today thinking of the two of you. In your first election, you'll get to vote for an African-American (if I ever learn that you did otherwise, well, it's a free country and you can do what you want, but don't bother coming home).

    AndrewGoodman-JamesChaney-M.jpgI can't resist taking note of this. Your parents wondered whether we would EVER get to do this. How did this happen? Well, it happened for lots of reasons. But you got to touch one of those reasons personally. We sat in Carolyn's house during that vacation (you know, the best Mishkin vacation ever because Melanie was with us) and she told you the story of Goodman, Schwerner and Chaney.

    Now, historians are quick to point out that we can't really prove why things happen in history; and we certainly can't prove that things would have been different if other things hadn't happened (if Lincoln hadn't been shot, would the U.S. have been different after the Civil War?).

    But I can tell you this: you wouldn't be voting for Obama today if Andy Goodman hadn't gone to Mississippi to register blacks to vote. When he was killed, it pricked the conscience of our country. We are a better country than that. It took his death, and those of Schwerner and Chaney, to make the country see that. The country was never the same. So although I cannot PROVE that history would have been different without Andy Goodman, I don't need proof. I know it.

    It would have been sweet had Carolyn lived to see what she and Andy and everyone else from Freedom Summer in Mississippi accomplished. As with Obama's grandmother, it wasn't meant to be. So be it. Think of her today. And Melanie, when you're with a million people tonight, give a cheer for me.

    Dad/Doug

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    Gardening Grandma said:

    Doug, how right you are!

    My first newspaper job was in Philadelphia, MS, where I lived for two years in the decade after the killings. Emotions were still quite high, and as a New York Jew, I wasn't particularly welcome in the community.

    In the 1972 election, there were less than dozen votes for George McGovern, and we knew the identity of every one. There were the Indian Health Service physicians and dentist and their wives, the editor of the Neshoba Democrat, the local vet and Florence Mars, author of Is Mississippi Burning.

    Last night, there were 2,584 votes cast for Obama in Neshoba County. Still just 26 percent, but yes, times have definitely changed.

    M. B. said:

    There are two national figures that were instrumental in making this possible - Lyndon B. Johnson of Texas and Hubert Humphrey of Minnesota. As Senators, they got the Voting Rights Act passed and later President Johnson pushed through the 1964 Civil Rights Act which brought the massive power of the federal government to bear against those who had rigged the system to keep blacks as second class citizens across the country. Humphrey was firmly committed to the cause of civil rights, but unable for years to overcome strong opposition and entrenched power of segregationists in Congress. Johnson used his ingenuity, skill, power and determination as Senate Majority Leader to get the necessary backing of key Southern Democrats for voting rights, as Robert Caro describes in Master of the Senate. There were also the courageous men who sat as judges, especially in the Fifth Circuit during the time of change and provided justice for the people of the South, ignoring all the pressure placed on them to preserve the traditional status quo. And we should not forget the Rev. Martin Luther King for inspiring a non-violent movement that, like Mohandas Ghandi, shamed the establishment into righting wrongs.

    Today, Mississippi has more elected African-American public officials than any other state. "Separate but equal" was revealed as a fraud and is a dead doctrine. Doors of opportunity have been opened across the country. And an African-American has been elected by mostly non-African-American voters to the highest office.

    Larry Kaufman said:

    Rabbi Andrew Davids posted it on FaceBook -- but it needs to be shared everywhere:

    Rosa sat, so that Martin could walk, so that Barack could run, so that our children can fly.

    Dorothy Serotta said:

    I remember the times you are recalling and the people we knew who were directly involved, including KIvie Kaplan, chair of the National Commission of Social Action of our movement; Al Vorspan, then its live wire spark and central core, Eugene Lipman of blessed memory, and so many others of that time. We would have found it difficult to believe that this current event could have come off this soon and this well.The future certainly looks wonderfully bright at this point, especially considering how far we allhave come.

    Yossi Gremillion said:

    I guess Separation of Church and State only applies if you are not a liberal (oh, I'm sorry, I meant PROGRESSIVE), to provide an endorsement on a religious website. Your "letter" to your daughters smacks of pompous, condescending expectations that your children think like you. By the way, I proudly voted for Barack Obama as the candidate because I felt that he was the right candidate for the job. I made the decision on my own. I respect all of the candidates who sacrificed their personal lives to be good servants of our country.

    Post a comment