RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    Finding Happiness in Israel, Even (and Especially) Now
    January 8, 2009
    Israel (6 comments)

    by Daphne Price
    Daphne Price is Rabbi David Saperstein's executive assistant.
    (First posted at
    RACblog)
    Jerusalem-sunrise.jpgI love watching the sun rise (though most of my sunrises coincide with vacation). This morning's sun rise was over the Old City of Jerusalem. We arrived in Israel last evening, and my 18 month old is having the worst time adjusting. For 4 hours or so, my baby and I strolled the halls of our hotel until the sun came up. 

    Despite the war in Israel, we decided to travel all the way here to "vacation" for 12 days with our two small children. We gave it a lot of thought and consulted many of our friends and relatives. We even considered going to Disney instead. In the end, my husband and I decided this was the right choice to make. Why?

    We love Israel. As our children grow, we want them to learn to love Israel. We want them to know Israeli culture and to learn her short and complicated history. We want them to understand Israel and Israelis - and all the good and bad that goes with it.  (And let's face it: They're not going to get an accurate read of the country by watching the news from our living room back in Maryland.)

    At 4 and a half years old, my oldest child has been here enough times that even she is familiar with our routines. She has friends and relatives she plays with. She knows that the zoo is in Jerusalem and the aquarium is in Eilat, and that her aunts and uncles live in Tel Aviv. She can name a half-dozen or so restaurants where we like to (love to!!!) eat - and she knows what she's going to order at each place. She knows where her favorite candy store is in Jerusalem. She knows the difference between a pita and a lafa, between tehina and hummus. And she knows that Israelis push and can be pushy.

    The other day, she asked me if we were still going to Israel. When I asked her why we wouldn't, she said she heard there are bad people there. I sighed. I tried to explain to her that yes, there were bad people, but if we were going, we wouldn't be near where the bad things are happening. I'm not sure she was convinced, but at that moment I decided that unless the situation escalated, and the attacks were expanded further into Israel, we were definitely going (otherwise, Disney!).

    I want her to see that her friends and relatives are still living their normal lives and that they still go to school and play (although granted, none of them live in the targeted areas). I want her to visit and eat and soak up the atmosphere. I don't ever want her to be afraid of visiting Israel. Yes, at this age, we'll shelter her as much as we can from the violence and the conflict - but we will take her to the store to buy toys for the children here who have to spend so much time hunkered down in their own shelters. Yes, we'll be more cautious over this next stretch of time. Yes, there will be places that we'll avoid on this trip. But the bottom line is that this is a happy place for us, and I want it to be happy place for her too. I want her to always look forward to visiting Israel.

    Of course, we hope for an end to the war and to bloodshed. We hope for peace. We hope we can keep coming back to Israel.

    As I spent the night roaming the halls, these thoughts and more went through my mind.
     
    My baby and I ended our night by feasting at breakfast overlooking the Old City, watching the sun rise. And I thought, in so many ways: Yes, this is my happy place.

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    M. B. said:

    I would not risk my childrens' safety by taking them to Israel at this time. Israel is never a safe place to visit considering the hostility between Israelis of different religions and ethnic groups, between Israelis and the people under occupation, and between Israelis and many of the people in neighboring countries, but some times are safer than others. War is unpredictable - much easier to start than either to control or to finish. Already it has escalated from rocket strikes out of and into Gaza to a ground invasion of Gaza followed by rocket strikes against northern Israel. Large Israeli cities which were out of range once, are now within striking distance of Hamas. Suicide bombing is also threatened. There may be a better time in the future, God wiling, to be in Israel. Especially if there is no necessity to have them there, you might at least consider not exposing children too young to decide for themselves whether to undertake such a risk.

    JanetheWriter said:

    Good for you, Daphne! For so many of us, opportunities to visit Israel are too few and far between and I applaud you and your family for doing what you believe is the right thing at this difficult time.

    My own first visit to Jerusalem in January 2004 happened to coincide with a rush-hour bus bombing in Rehavia that killed 11 and injured scores more. Indeed, January 29, 2004 was a sad and scary day, but, in true Israeli style, we carried on with our itinerary, which then included stopping at a streetside news stand in the evening to watch the names of the dead and wounded scroll by on the television. I could not have had a more Israeli slice-of-life experience.

    I hope that you savor this visit, not only for yourselves and your children, but, especially now, for all of us whose hearts are in the east.

    penk said:

    I'm not going to question what I believe are MB's good intentions in suggesting that there may be safer times to travel to Israel. On the other hand, I do take issue with MB's seeming to accuse Ms. Price of some form of child neglect/harm.

    I also wonder about the following:

    1. Israel is *never* a safe place to visit? Considering that there is always tension among Israelis and between Israel and her neighbors and those who live within Israel, when would MB suggest *is* a "safer" time to visit?

    2. I intend NO sarcasm here but respectfully ask whom MB considers "the people under occupation?" Given that criteria, would MB suggest that travelers not visit Texas, California, New York, Florida, Arizona, France, England, Ireland, India, etc.? Are people living in those areas also "people under occupation?" Or is that label reserved only for Israel?

    Joseph said:

    I applaud your bravery Daphne Price. It reminds me of when my grandmother, may she rest in peace, visited Israel decades ago. Terrorists attacked the airport she was scheduled to land in a few days before her vacation. Relative tried to convince her to stay in the US, but she refused to let terroism cancel her plans.

    M. B. said:

    Penk: The "people under occupation" are those who live in the territories which Israel occupied over 40 years ago in the 1967 war. They have not chosen to live in Israel and do not have the rights of Israeli citizens (save and except for some in Jerusalem who may now opt to be naturalized). These people live under military occupation and their status is determined under international law. They have not been integrated into Israeli schools, neighborhoods, businesses, or society society in general and it appears that most in Israel do not want them to be citizens in the state of Israel, even if they chose to become citizens. I am not including in the definition of people under occupation, any of the non-Jewish Israeli citizens (over 20% of Israelis now being Arab).

    I see no problem with visiting Texas, California, New York, Florida, Arizona, France, England, and Ireland, which are not under occupation. In fact, now is a great time to explore our own country which has been blessed with incredible natural beauty and man made wonders. There is so much to see here and so few of us who have seen most of it. Also, the stronger dollar makes travel even more attractive to France, England, Ireland and other parts of the EU which also have vibrant Jewish communities to connect with and interesting historical and cultural sites to visit.

    The government has issued a Travel Warning for Americans visiting Israel, the West Bank and Gaza which can be found at http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/tw/tw_922.html which includes: "The Department of State urges U.S. citizens to remain mindful of security factors when planning travel to Israel. In addition, the Department of State urges U.S. citizens to defer travel to the West Bank and to avoid all travel to the Gaza Strip.
    ...
    Israeli authorities remain concerned about the continuing threat of terrorist attacks.
    ...
    American citizens are urged to exercise a high degree of caution and common sense when patronizing restaurants, nightclubs, cafes, malls, places of worship, and theaters -- especially during peak hours. Large crowds and public gatherings have been targeted by terrorists in the past and should be avoided to the extent practicable."

    I have personally gone to some places in the past which were not the safest, but that doesn't mean I would take by family there.

    Doris said:

    Re the Gov. warning, please note the date is from mid September and I did make note of it....I did an ARZA tour starting Oct. 19th and we even went to Akko. While my trip was 9 day, longer trip participants went to the South. I felt very safe the entire time.

    A local friend advised me prior to the trip...and reassured me that Israel knows my every move/location every moment. Secondly, that they get Americans to specific shelters immediately if need arises.

    I am so glad I went on this first trip to Israel! It opened my eyes to so many things both current and ancient. Then once home again I read the book 'The Israelis' and it greatly enlarged my perception of difficulties within Israel in everyday matters and people.

    Had my trip been booked during the current crisis, I would not cancel.

    Post a comment