RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    Living in Torah Time
    April 20, 2009
    Holidays | Torah (9 comments)

    By Marge Eiseman
    I've always wondered why the Torah reading about the Exodus didn't occur at the time of year when we celebrate Passover. And shouldn't we be reading about receiving the Ten Commandments at Shavu'ot? Doesn't that make more sense? Why are we in the midst of all the rules for the Levites and how to properly offer sacrifices, when it's time for us to act "as if" we were there at the plagues and the preparation for crossing the sea?

    I've probably referred to this before, but my friends and I talk about living in "Torah Time" - when the themes of the weekly Torah portion either reflect or shape our modern experiences. So today, at 88 year old great uncle Archie's funeral, I had this idea that maybe it's what we put into these connections, this synchronicity that gives it some oomph!

    I listened to the rabbi speak about how this very accomplished man was like matzah in his humility and service to nourish community. All who knew him in life, had memories of his very opinionated style of speaking, arguing cases and being the family storyteller, and as one of the speakers said, one quality he had little of was doubt. And yet, when the rabbi likened him to the humble flat bread that symbolizes the holiday during which Uncle Archie died, people nodded like that really captured his essence.

    I guess in Torah Time, not everything has to line up perfectly, but it all sort of makes sense.

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    Larry Kaufman said:

    Marge, our Rabbis teach that there is no earlier or later in Torah -- and by the same principle, I first wrote that our Rabbis taught, then realized that the teaching is as alive today as when it was first pronounced.

    I marvel at the ability of our contemporary rabbis, particularly pronounced at this state of the cycle, to find contemporary messages in the arcane minutiae of Leviticus -- and particularly Professor Adler's skill at presenting such serious ideas with a light hand and a humorour touch.

    To paraphrase your lovely metaphor, in Torah Time, we bring our sensibility to the line-up, so we synchronize ourselves with the text rather than asking it to synchronize with us.

    M. B. said:

    The reading of the Torah in most Jewish services, at least until the Jewish Reformation in the 19th Century "follows the custom consolidated by Babylonian Jewry during the period of the Sages and the geonim" according to the Jewish Study Bible, p. 1930. Portions were divided up for 54 weeks (using a lunar calendar). The five books of Ruth, Esther, Lamentations, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs were scheduled more topically. The reading of the prophetic books of the Bible was probably added in the Second Temple period. Id. at 1932. The translation of the Bible portions into the vernacular,e.g. Greek or Aramaic, etc., also traced to ancient times because the Hebrew was already not understood by the congregations.

    While this is one way to structure services so that one can follow along from week to week, it is not, in my opinion, an adequate approach to serious study of the Bible. The narrow focus avoids the examination of the differing treatment of the same topic at various points in the Bible, and prevents one from ever seeing the forest for the trees. The portion of the week ("parashat") method also makes it difficult to timely consider the application of the Holy Scriptures to topics of current interest, whether they affect the world, the nation, the community or just individuals. We see this happen repeatedly in this blog, where instead of looking at headline events, we are distracted with untimely, inapplicable and unhelpful portions. This blog, for some strange reason, completely omits among its topics most of the Bible, limiting discussion to the Torah. I don't know how a progressive stream of Judaism can justify that omission when, unlike the Orthodox, Reform rejects the old idea of the Torah having been divinely revealed to Moses at Mt. Sinai along with the Ten Commandments.

    If we are to keep Bible study relevant and to engage in historical, critical, study of the Bible, we should select passages to consider in a flexible manner.

    BZ said:

    M.B. writes:
    The reading of the Torah in most Jewish services, at least until the Jewish Reformation in the 19th Century "follows the custom consolidated by Babylonian Jewry during the period of the Sages and the geonim" according to the Jewish Study Bible, p. 1930.

    What Jewish congregations do you know of (even after the "Jewish Reformation") that don't use this cycle of parshat hashavua?

    M. B. said:

    The Jewish Reformation enabled women to read from the Torah. Before the Reformation, there were seven or more readers who were called to actually read from the Torah in keeping with the Mishnah, although they did not necessarily understand the Hebrew they were vocalizing. After reform, those called to the pulpit during the Torah reading might only say a blessing before the reading of another portion of the Torah, enabling those who could not read Hebrew to participate in the ceremonial reading from the scroll. Before the Reformation, reading priority depended on what tribe the reader was considered a member of. After reform, all Jews are equal. Practice varies from temple to temple, but in some congregations, the rabbi will translate as he or she reads, sentence by sentence.

    The reading of a portion of the Prophets section of the Bible was the conclusion (haftarah) of the Torah reading, since the Second Temple era. Jewish Study Bible, p. 1932. Before the Jewish Reformation, it was read by the last Torah reader, but now it may be read by another participant.

    Simcha Daniel Burstyn said:

    I've often found this frustrating, too, but this year things have been falling into place for me - I'm seeing connections between the Parsha and the time of year - for example, Parashat Shmini right after Pessach - Pessach is, after all, all about kashrut and food and not eating (or, in the case of Nadav and Avihu, drinking) "just anything" - and here is Shmini - also all about food and kashrut and not eating "just anything".

    I noticed in the winter, too, that discussing the hardened heart of Pharaoh then is substantially different than discussing it in the springtime around the seder table - in the winter, a hardened heart might be connected to the weather, whereas now it's about the history.

    And in the fall, after we've had everyone together for the High holidays and for Sukkot, it's so much fun to see them responding to the very accessible Torah readings of Genesis - they might even keep coming to shul for a few more Shabbatot.

    I'm sure that the Rabbis of ancient Babylonia were thinking the same thoughts we Jewish professionals are thinking today - thoughts like "How can we get more yidden to shul?" "How can we make this predictable enough to keep them paying our salaries?"

    Also, remember that the Babylonian synagogue was a house of study primarily - so it makes sense to read these portions when they come up - it rounds out the curriculum across the whole year. Most of our present day approach in which we teach that "keeping up with the times means keeping up with the parsha" grow out of a Chabad practice from the Ba'al HaTanya, who said just that. Teaching Dvarim with Moses' sermons in the summer makes for good prep for the High Holidays. Teaching Vayikra with all the rules about sacrifice in the early spring - just before the lambing season - makes for good prep for slaughtering season. Etc.

    BZ said:

    After reform, those called to the pulpit during the Torah reading might only say a blessing before the reading of another portion of the Torah, enabling those who could not read Hebrew to participate in the ceremonial reading from the scroll.

    This is nothing new, and has been almost universal in the Jewish world for about 1000 years.

    But what does any of this have to do with which portion is read (going sequentially through the Torah vs. "topics of current interest"), the subject of your previous comment?

    M. B. said:

    BZ: What do you mean by the term "parashat hashuva?" I am not familiar with that term.

    BZ said:

    M.B.:
    "Parashat hashavua" = "portion of the week" (which you refer to in your own comment)

    PK said:

    You will be happy to know that we do read about receiving the Aseret haDibrot (10 Words/Commandments) on Shavuot.

    While you have read several good historical reports on how the Torah readings were ordered, I think that you may be asking a more profound question. Indeed, there is some evidence that Ezra, who may have instituted the readings after the return from Babylonian Exile, expected the readings to take place at festivals and to consist of what the Torah had to say about the occasion.

    What we have now is like a Jewish "bio-rhythm", one pattern overlain with another. The Torah, because it contains more than accounts of festivals and because we need to drink it all every year, doesn't distribute over the holidays exactly. Its rhythm begins and ends at Simchat Torah. This rhythm is enhanced by extra readings at festivals. Festivals also are part of our spiritual core. At Rosh Chodesh we add another type of cycle with its particular readings. And so, throughout the year, we work to stay aware of the different strands of our religious lives just as we combine all that with an awareness of our secular lives!

    The most amazing connections can be made by studying the Torah portion of the week with an eye toward what is happening both in the religious and secular realms of our lives.

    May your experience of studying Torah always be new and refreshing.

    Post a comment