RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    Galilee Diary: Laughter
    December 15, 2009
    Israel (8 comments)

    by Marc Rosenstein
    (Originally published in
    Ten Minutes of Torah and Galilee Diary)

    Thus said the Lord: Again there shall be heard in this place, which you say is ruined, without man or beast - in the towns of Judah and the streets of Jerusalem that are desolate, without man, without inhabitants, without beast - the sound of mirth and gladness... -Jeremiah 33:10-11

    So there I was on the train from Tel Aviv, coming home to the Galilee, on a Tuesday evening after rush hour. The train was nevertheless full - I had to walk through two cars to find a seat. The passengers on these late trains seem to be characterized by their tiredness - it has been a long day. Many people doze and/or listen to their ipods, some read books (they read the tabloid on the way to work - there's nothing left to read in it by evening), more and more work on their laptops. There are always a few passengers travelling with a friend or acquaintance or coworker, who actually converse during the ride; a much larger number are conversing with someone far away, by cell phone - you can hear them all - the soldier breaking up with her boyfriend, the teenager arguing with his mother, the foreman barking work instructions, the mother guiding her kid through dinner preparations. Conversations in Hebrew and Russian and Arabic and English and occasionally Amharic. Seems like the harder you try not to listen, the more you hear. I've noticed, too, that many who are not talking on their cell phones are nevertheless busy with them, texting or playing games or exploring "features."

    The train ridership is pretty heterogeneous: yuppies and hippies, lots of soldiers and police (who ride free), college students, families on outings, tourists from the airport, Arabs and Jews, Orthodox and not, old and young, rich and poor.

    And as we dozed and chatted our way through the darkness, speeding north along the coast, somewhere before Haifa a young woman with a Russian accent, sitting with a friend near the center of the car, broke out into a fit of hysterical laughter. It was a nice laugh, not annoying, real and happy and a little musical. But after the first outburst, she got trapped in a feedback loop and couldn't stop. Her peals of laughter filled the car - there was no way you could ignore them. Some people stood up or craned their necks to see what was going on. And ultimately, just about everyone found him/herself smiling or even laughing out loud. Strangers sitting side by side commented to each other with a smile, enjoying the shared experience. For about ten minutes all of us were lifted out of our tired, hungry, bored, anxious-to-be-somewhere-else, lonely reality and brought together by an experience of shared joy. We all knew it was silly, and meaningless, and yet we were all laughing in spite of ourselves, and feeling permitted to do so by the fact that the strangers sitting around us were laughing too.

    Mass behavior - or shared humanity?

    Put us in a sealed train, cut us off from our ethnic, class, religious, and ideological identities, and it turns out we can, now and then, find and recognize and even enjoy the underlying human elements that we all have in common.

    Finally the laugher's friends managed to calm her down, and the ambient noise of train sounds and cell-phone cacophony took over again, and the train stopped at Haifa and started to empty out, and we all went back to how and what we had been before. Or did we?

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    Alanna said:

    And thousands of miles away, days (or perhaps months) after her laughter infected you and the other passengers, I sit and smile in front of my computer. The sounds of mirth and gladness fill my heart, too.

    Thanks, Marc!

    Ivy Pearlstein said:

    This is a beautiful story that demonstrates how people can find connectedness and experience the joy of that connectedness. I believe that everyone on that train has been changed by this experience because now they have all been opened to the possibility that that connectedness can happen again. When they have another experience like this, and they will, the strength of that connection to other people will grow. They were all stuck on that train. We are all stuck on this planet. My prayer is for more connections and more joy to be experienced by more and more different people.

    Soldann(aka Stan Greenberg, PhD), Colrain, MA, USA said:

    Marc, thanks for this and your continuing, meaningful work and sharings. This was beautiful,informative, uplifting, and fun! Wishing you and yours infinite blessings....

    Jessica said:

    Here is a film with this same theme:


    http://bit.ly/8tn9Fw

    grace shohet said:

    Much as I appreciated (and enjoyed) these thoughts, I don't think a generic discussion of the benefits of laughter--even on a multi-ethnic bus in Israel--qualifies as "torah study." The text is so rich: What is the textual context? HOW, in Jeremiah, can laughter return to a place "without man or beast"? How did the place BECOME so desolate? Does the absence of laughter itself create desolation? What do commentators say? I'd like to learn more about TORAH, and less about laughter per se. But perhaps I misunderstand the purposes of this service...?

    Janet Richmond said:

    I loved this! Rabbi Rosenstein's words brought me right into the train with him--watching and listening to all the different languages, seeing all the different people.

    I, too, have traveled on this train from Tel Aviv to Haifa; alas, not since my last trip to Israel, in March 2008. On my train ride there were flocks of soldiers among the other rush hour commuters. I was particularly drawn to these young people-physically beautiful and strong, laughing and socializing with each other, and ready-- at a moment's notice-- to protect our beloved homeland.

    Thanks to Rabbi Rosenstein, I was on that train again today. And, it was a very good trip indeed.

    Deborah said:

    This reminds me of the quote from Mark Twain:

    The human race has one really effective weapon, and that is laughter.

    Sally Sanders said:

    Laughter is a mitzvah.

    Laughter enables you to face adversities and to overcome difficult experiences. It enables you to gather strength when you desperately need it. Yes, laughter is good for the heart.

    Post a comment