RJ.org News and Views of Reform Jews
 
About | Submissions | Contact
topics

  • Torah
  • Defining Reform
  • Jewish History
  • Jewish Living
  • Community
  • Social Action
  • Israel/World
  • Holidays
  • Shabbat
  • Lifecycle
  • Youth & Family
  • College Life
  • Books
  • Ask The Rabbi

    Get Jewish World News in your inbox

    BOOKS & MUSIC

    Inside Intermarriage
    Inside Intermarriage:
    A Christian Partner's Perspective on Raising a Jewish Family

    by Jim Keen
    (URJ Press)

    The Torah
    The Torah: A Women's Commentary
    (URJ Press)

    Union for Reform Judaism

    Galilee Diary: Shabbat shalom
    March 2, 2010
    Israel (6 comments)

    by Marc Rosenstein
    (Originally published in
    Ten Minutes of Torah and Galilee Diary)

    You shall destroy all the peoples that the Lord your God delivers to you, showing them no pity. And you shall not worship their gods, for that would be a snare to you.

    --Deuteronomy 7:16

    Six months ago, our daughter Ilana, seeking a non-urban, inexpensive apartment near Haifa, moved to the Druze Arab village of Usfiya. This town is just beyond the outskirts of Haifa as you go south along the top of the Carmel ridge, less than ten minutes from Haifa University. Because of its location it has been considered as a sort of suburb of Haifa for decades - and yet, for all its development and its economic interdependence with Haifa, it retains many features of a rural Arab village.

    The Druze constitute about 10% of Israel's million Arab citizens. They believe that the founder of their religion was Moses' father-in-law Jethro, and thus it antedates Islam (the shrine of Jethro's tomb, in the mountains above Tiberias, called Nebi Shuaib, is a major pilgrimage site); on the other hand, historians argue that the religion was founded in Egypt in the 11 th century as a split-off from Islam; persecuted by the Muslims, the Druze ultimately concentrated their communities in the mountains of what later became Lebanon and Syria (where the vast majority live today) and northern Israel. The two southernmost Druze villages in Israel are Usfiya and its neighbor, Daliyat el-Carmel. After 1948 the Druze leadership agreed that Druze men would be subject to the Israeli military draft, and indeed, they have served with distinction in all branches of the army since then. That is perhaps the reason that many Jewish Israelis don't define them as Arabs. It is quite common for Arab villages in Israel to be of mixed religion, and indeed, Usfiya is home to some Moslem and Christian Arab families, as well as quite a few Jews, especially university students.

    Ilana's spacious, airy apartment is attached to a single family home belonging to a young couple (+ two little kids and a dog); Nasrin is a guidance counselor; Alaa is a career army officer, marathon runner, and PhD candidate in history. His father was until his recent retirement the director of education for the Israel National Parks Authority. His brother and family live next door. They are the picture of middle-class life and aspirations, friendly and hospitable, busy with all the demands of modern life but still finding time to tend the garden and fruit trees and chickens - for this is, after all, not a suburb, but a village. They appear to live quite comfortably in two very different cultures, two languages - they seem to have had the talent and/or luck to succeed at and even enjoy living on the cultural seam.

    We spent last Shabbat there, on a beautiful spring-like winter day. We took a hike down a nearby valley, walking through a densely oak-shaded canyon where the smell of moss reminded us of hikes in the old country, out to expanses of rolling meadows dotted with wildflowers, where shepherds tended their flocks and farmers tended their tractors. It is not for nothing that parts of the Carmel range are nicknamed "little Switzerland." As we climbed back up a different valley toward the main highway from Haifa, we began to encounter groups of Jewish families hiking, and when we got to the road, there were Jewish and Arab families picnicking under every tree. The village itself was one big traffic jam: Usfiya and Daliyah are major Shabbat outing destinations for residents of Haifa and even Tel Aviv. Daliyah has a well-developed crafts market; in Usfiya the attractions are furniture stores, plant nurseries, and restaurants. As we walked along the strip of stores I noticed that while the spoken language in Usfiya is Arabic, the signs on the shops were almost entirely in Hebrew.

    Could it be that we are on the way to creating some kind of shared Israeli culture here after all - with economic forces driving the process?

    print Print     email Email     comment Comment    

     

    Comments

    Larry Kaufman said:

    On our first trip to Israel, in 1975, my mother z"l, who was then living in Tel Aviv, took us to visit her friends in Daliyat HaCarmel. I don't remember their names, but I do recall that our hostess was the first Druze woman to graduate from college in Israel, and was the daughter of the former mayor. I also remember that we were overwhelmed with hospitality, and that there was a palpable sense that the relations between Israelis and Druze were on a different level than those between Israelis and other Arab communities.

    From what you say of your daughter's community, I get more of a feeling of status quo than significant progress in 35 years towards a shared culture. I would be delighted to be wrong.

    Paul said:

    One reasonable interpretation of your story is that, through assimilation and community blending, cultures are being destroyed as surely (though presumably less quickly) as the directive from Deuteronomy. Do we have an obligation to preserve cultures that we unknowingly or inevitably displace, or is change the only constant and, with change, comes transformation? In this sense, your daughter is as much an instrument of community destruction as a bulldozer (well, this is a little too dramatic, but hopefully you get my point).

    Harold Clumeck said:

    This is in response to Paul. Paul, you make the claim that Rabbi Rosenstein's daughter, by moving into an Arab village, is being "an instrument of community destruction." So what are you suggesting? That Jews should not move into Arab neighborhoods? Arabs should not move into Jewish neighborhoods? Blacks should not move into white neighborhoods? When different cultures start rubbing up against each other, of course they get affected and changed. You said "hopefully you get my point." No, I don't, Paul, I don't get your point at all.

    Paul said:

    Harold, please don't imply a subtext to my comments; community destruction is, in my opinion, an inevitability. I am not advocating cultural separation, merely pointing out that integration comes with a price. It also comes with enormous benefits which, in my opinion, far outweigh any loss. This brings us back to the Deuteronomic imperative: "You shall destroy all the peoples". In my mind, I choose to believe that this directive is not necessarily underscored with anger or venom; it merely states that change over time results in some things being lost which were held dear, and some of those things are/were good and some are/were less good. Arabs and Jews, Blacks and Whites, Amish and uptight, upstate New Yorkers; each cultural representative loses some uniqueness over time as they assimilate and, as this happens, the old "person" is "destroyed", making room for a new, hopefully better, person.

    Stan Selbst said:

    My comment is baruch HaShem. Economics may well be the best way to achieve peace. It creates a level playing field where everyone can be a winner.

    Your articles are wonderful. I look froward to them every week.

    Betsy Roth said:

    Hi all,
    I remember living in Israel during the 80's. Every Shabbat, with Jerusalem shut up tight, my husband and I would go on a well worn road to Bethelehem...as would every other secular Jew. We would eat at the grill restaurants and then go shopping in the makolets to find the occasional can of Ocean Spray Cranbeery Sauce! As a belly dancing student, we would then spend our evenings in the night clubs in Bethelehem dancing the night away with the locals....until the first Intifada erupted and then what seemed like true peace, a great economy and a yearning to live as family was totally destroyed. Mark, I was once where you are now. I had lived in Israel for 15 years up until the Intafada. Then I had to leave...my dream of peace with our neighbors was gone and so was the life I knew.

    We will be visiting over Pesach. All the best! Betsy

    Post a comment